Butera's - Bay Shore

Name: Butera's - Bay Shore
Address: 8 Third Ave, Bay Shore, New York, 11706, US
Telephone: (631) 328-4948
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Italian, Pizza, Bars

Hours:
8 Third Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 328-4948

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Butera's - Bay Shore

Butera's is a highly recommended restaurant known for its exceptional Sunday brunch, diverse menu, and friendly, professional staff. Guests often enjoy the large portions, especially during happy hour, where the food and drinks are terrific. The restaurant has a reputation for catering to large parties like rehearsal dinners and birthday celebrations, providing excellent service and delicious food. The Sunday sauce special is very good, and the chicken cutlet has been described as excellent. Recent reviews highlight the wonderful Shrimp limoncello and the delicious pork chop, which are favorites among guests. The shrimp entree and raspberry cheesecake also receive high praise. Service has sometimes been inconsistent, with some guests needing to ask multiple times for water glasses to be filled, but overall, the friendly staff like Nancy make for a pleasant dining experience. Nancy was praised for her warm, family-like vibe and her thoughtful gesture of surprising a guest with a chocolate cookie. For busy nights, such as Fridays and Saturdays, reservations are recommended due to the smaller dining area. Many guests have found the food amazing and keep returning, especially for dishes like Veal Milanese and Thai calamari. Overall, Butera's remains a popular spot for quality food, generous portions, and friendly service.