Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream
75 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
(631) 666-2229
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Fudge Chunk
Waffle Bowl Sundae
Mint Oreo Cookie
Monster Crunch
Whipped Cream
Banana Oreo
Toppings
Sundaes
Menu
Photos
+57 photos
+56 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Ana at Bay Shore Coyle's did an amazing job with our birthday cake. She was very thorough and made sure all the details were right and went above and beyond to make us the cake we wanted. Thanks again Ana for all your help and making this birthday memorable.
The ice cream is delicious and a top go to for when my boyfriend and I crave ice cream. All the staff are on top of making sure they’re helping customers. The only complaint I have is that the place is relatively small with little space to move and see the flavors when it’s crowded, not a deal breaker though
Oh em GEE! This ice cream is unbelievably good! This combination might seem odd, but the strawberry crunch is the best I’ve ever had and the Cookie Monster feels like a taste of childhood!!! The girls working behind the counter are all incredibly nice as well. The atmosphere feels very chill and overall a great experience. Would def recommend for anyone looking for delicious and sweet ice cream!
Kid-friendliness: They have a local student of the month event...
Kid-friendliness: They have a local student of the month event...
You May Also Like
Grace Deli - 77 Howells Rd
![]()
Sandwich Shop, American, Deli
Marcony's Pizza & Pasta Restaurant - 73 Howells Rd
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian
Bayshore Bagels & Deli - 222 5th Ave
![]()
Bagels, Pet Friendly