Fatfish
$$$ • Seafood, Vegetarian
Hours:
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 666-2899
About Fatfish
Customers' Favorites
Fatfish Reviews
Share your opinion about Fatfish
Everything was wonderful! We had a lovely luncheon!
While the service and atmosphere were great the food was mediocre at best because of a lack seasoning
Beautiful atmosphere! Great live music! Excellent service
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 9:30PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 9:30PM |
| Sunday | 11:30AM - 5:30PM |
Fatfish offers a great dining experience with excellent service and a stunning waterfront view. The restaurant is now well-staffed, making it easier to reserve a table. The menu features delicious options, including the ceviche appetizer, halibut special, lamb chops, tuna tacos, and empanadas. The service is first-class, and the ambiance is perfect for a romantic evening or special occasion, with live music adding to the mood. Guests often praise the food, especially the ceviche and seafood dishes like mussels with chorizo and Branzino, which are described as delicious and full of flavor. The staff are known for providing great service and making diners feel welcomed. The outdoor seating is ideal when the weather is nice, offering a beautiful view that enhances the dining experience. This wonderful restaurant right on the Great South Bay offers outstanding food and location. Appetizers, drinks, main dinners like Lobster, Branzino, Lobster Bisque, Shrimp, and dessert are enjoyed by many. The food remains outstanding, and the location adds to the overall experience. Making a reservation provides peace of mind, knowing a table is waiting. Guests seated outside directly over the water enjoy dishes like beef carpaccio and mushroom gnocchi, which are delicious. Tuna (rare) and open ravioli are cooked to perfection, and key lime pie is a delightful summer treat. Visitors have celebrated special occasions here, such as anniversaries and birthdays. The scenery is beautiful, romantic, and serene, perfect for a memorable evening. The food and ambiance are generally amazing, with incredible views. Service is friendly and attentive, although some guests felt rushed during their birthday dinner with friends. Overall, Fatfish remains a favorite spot for a lovely meal with a wonderful atmosphere, offering excellent seafood and a scenic waterfront setting.