Custom Cakes near Bayport, NY

Berry Fresh Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
897 Montauk Hwy, Bayport

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt

“Love this place. This best frozen yogurt and so many toppings even though I only take one. Kids will love it. It is very clean and every person who ever waited on me there has provided good service and had a positive attitude. Tuesday is buy one get one. Love the tart flavor and good old vanilla the best. There are many flavors to choose from.“

4.3 Superb12 Reviews
Cake Fairyland Bakery • $
1320 Stony Brook Rd building c, Stony Brook - 10.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Mille Crepe Cake
Strawberry Crepe Cake
Strawberry Box Cakes
Pistachio Cheesecake
Strawberry Fruit Tea
Chocolate Cake
Rainbow Crepe
Birthday Cake
Carrot Cake
Taro Puff

“I actually never heard of this place, but I was searching for Teramasu online and I came across this place. So I order a slice of Teramasu, I have to say it was absolutely delicious, and it came in a nice pink box with flatware on a flat black plate. I will definitely order from this place and definitely visit this place , I highly recommend. If you had a sudden urge for desert like I did, love it❤️❤️❤️????“

4.6 Superb46 Reviews
Benkert's Bakery Bakery • $$
2216 Middle Country Rd, Centereach - 8.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whipped Cream Birthday Cake
Death by Chocolate Cake
Cake with Strawberries
Strawberry Cheesecake
Brooklyn Cheesecake
Black Forest Cake
Sunflower Cupcake
Custom Kids Cake
Funfetti Cupcake
Unicorn Cupcake

“Benkert’s is our go-to for everything bakery related. We’ve never had anything we didn’t love from them. We got our wedding cake from them and it’s truly the most beautiful cake I’ve ever seen, and I’m still getting compliments on how it looked and tasted weeks later. When we were ordering they were very flexible with flavors and gave us plenty of options, they didn’t say no to anything we wanted, everything was possible. You can tell they really care about what they do. You are in good hands with Benkert’s.“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
Alpine Pastry Shop Bakery • $$
59 NY-111, Smithtown - 10.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli Pastries German Black Forrest Cake w Brandied Cherries
Whipped Cream Birthday Cake with Blueberries Fresh
German Black Forest Cake w Brandied Cherries
Specialty Occasion Ordered Custom Cake
Butter Cream Birthday Cake
Rainbow Cookies 1 2 Pound
Cassata Cake Cannoli 7 O
Italian Butter Cookies
Chocolate 7 Layer Cake
German Chocolate Cake

“Alpine truly can do it all“

4.1 Good142 Reviews
Swirls & Twirls Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
248 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset - 8.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt

“I absolutely love swirls and twirls. I come here every week and their prices are so reasonable. So many flavors and toppings to choose from. My favorite part is how clean everything thing is and how lovely the staff is. I would definitely recommend!“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews
Cupcakes Galore Dessert • $
117 A S Country Rd, Bellport - 5.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Cookie Cupcake
Birthday Cake Cupcake
Ferrero Rocher
Cannoli

“absolutely delicious, homemade, fresh cupcakes. the owner is such a delight! so privileged to have this business in our village of bellport!“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Sugar Dreams Bakery Bakery
15 S Country Rd, East Patchogue - 3.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake Great
Turnover

“Really like this bakery. My first order was a customized M & M cake, and communication as to the day got mixed up. They raced to get the cake made for my office party regardless and delivered it on time. The cake was delicious as well. Ive ordered there several times after, and have never been disappointed.“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
Paisapan Bakery Bakery • $
385 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 6.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Arepa Rellena Corn Cake Filled With
Arepa Cornbread with Beef
Empanadas Carne O Pollo
Calentado Paisa
Fajitas Mixtas
Birthday Cake
Bandeja Paisa
Quesadillas
Pan Queso
Bakery

“Deliciosos pasteles, postres y comida.“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
499 Sunrise Hwy Ste 57, Patchogue - 2.73 miles

“Nick at Cold Stone Creamery provided exceptional service! He was friendly, patient, and made sure our ice cream creations were perfect. His attention to detail and positive attitude made the visit even better. Highly recommend stopping by if Nick is there—you won’t be disappointed“

3.7 Good24 Reviews