Bethpage Bagels
$ • Bagels
Hours:
442 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 931-8428
About Bethpage Bagels
Customers' Favorites
Bethpage Bagels Reviews
Share your opinion about Bethpage Bagels
I am in town for the weekend and stopped in for coffee and breakfast at about 11 am on a Saturday. I was originally going to pick up food to head back over to the airbnb but ended up staying while I ate a chicken empanada, an Everything Flagel (flat bagel) with lox cream cheese, and a cup of coffee. As I ate, a lot of people came and went and seemed to know the place really well. It appears to be a family business and the customer service is friendly and efficient. The parking is plentiful and convenient, and the place is clean with a great assortment of fresh bagels. The coffee is fresh and average tasting. I was amazed at how many people ordered ordered bagels with the inside fluff scooped out, which I have been doing forever. This is why I was so happy to discover the Flagel which I asked them to scoop out anyway, but there was less to scoop out because it is already flat. I'm interested only in the crispy part, not the soft bready part inside. The empanada was great. They have chicken and beef. If you buy 6 of them, then the 7th one is free. The dessert/sweets assortment varied from things that looked homemade to packaged cookies to muffins from Costco. To go, I bought 2 more garlic bagels with lox and regular cream cheese, a bagel with some homemade chicken salad, a beef and a chicken empanada, plus a black-and-white cookie (which was fresh and delicious even though it was prepackaged.) This place is great, and I wish there was one like this where I live in Redondo Beach, CA. The only negative thing I have to say about Bethpage Bagels is that I wish that they would accept some form of payment other than only cash. Even if it were Venmo, CashApp, or PayPal, any other option would be an easier and more sanitary way to pay for food. I don't like seeing people in a food establishment handling dirty coins and bills if they are also putting food into bags and containers. That's the only reason why I didn't give this place a 5-star rating. If this were not a cash only establishment, I would've purchased 7 empanadas to go, instead of only 2!
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
| Tuesday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 5:30AM - 2PM |
People in Bethpage Also Viewed
Bethpage Bagels is a beloved cash-only bagel shop known for its delicious food and friendly staff. The restaurant features a cozy dining area, making it a popular spot for locals. Customers particularly enjoy the soft, sweet bialys and tasty egg sandwiches. The bagels are baked fresh in-house every day, offering a pillowy texture with the perfect amount of chew. The everything bagel with the vegetable cream cheese, made with fresh scallions and radishes, is a customer favorite, although some have noted that it could use more veggies. The staff is kind and helpful, ensuring customers feel right at home. Service is always quick, and the prices are very fair. Despite being a cash-only establishment, Bethpage Bagels is widely regarded as one of the best breakfast spots on the island.