“Ordered from here this morning and they were great. They do in store free delivery and we’re quick to get our order to us. They cooked our sandwiches as asked without any issues. Highly recommended deli, staff and service! We finally found our neighborhood deli!!“
“I ordered catering for my daughter's rehearsal dinner and the owner went out of his way to make sure the food was hot and perfect! All my guests raved about the food. It was so good and they gained a customer for life. The hot food they serve everyday is also so good.I highly recommend the food and they really care about their customers.“
“My office is right around the corner so I hear alot of great things about the food. I stopped in to talk to the owner to cater a party for me. I told him what I wanted and he gave me a reasonable price. He delivered at exactly the time we agreed and everyone loved it. So much food! Professional people!“
“Really good food. I have gastro issues so I am really careful where I eat out, but this place makes a great sandwich in a clean kitchen and I never have any problems, even with some heavier choices. Yes, eating lunch costs a lot of money now people, $15 for a sandwich and a drink is normal everywhere… that’s kinda how inflation works.“
“Let me say I’m not one to leave reviews, but i just had to for these guys. If u are reading this and have not tried there food. U would be crazy not to give them a shot. Hands down every ingredient they use is top quality. More then the food i love seeing these people. Never has a deli made me feel welcomed. You guys are the best and deserve all the customers in the world ❤️“
“Great old school deli I always try to stop at when I'm working in Bay Shore. I've never had anything that wasn't outstanding..BEC. cmon, had an unbelievable omlette today. Lunch is always fantastic with lots of specialty sandwiches. Best part is the people, so friendly and helpful, you leave happier than when you walk in! Great place, give it a try!“
“Went quite early in the morning... on the way to the Ronkonkoma train stain. The helpful girl behind the counter got mine & my coworker's order right ✅. Everyone enjoyed their breakfast on the way to Manhattan. The bacon was cooked perfectly, the cheese wasn't melted enough on my breakfast sandwich; but that's minor. Besides that, we were happy all- around. We will definitely be back / order here again.“
“The BEST deli in Smithtown. Their food is incredible. Especially the German Potato Salad. You MUST TRY IT! It's the best potato salad I've ever eaten, super unique & unlike any potato salad I've had. I will continue to come back. I got the Italian hero and it was so delicious!! NOT ONLY is the food amazing but the staff are all so friendly and kind. Extremely personable and they made me feel so welcomed & appreciated. Tom is a stand up guy & so pleasant to speak to. The place has some real charm and personality & has a wide selection of all the deli essentials. I would give 10 stars if I could!! You have to try Weinisch's Deli!!! You'll never go anywhere else again!!“
“I've been coming to this deli for about a year now and somehow after having the bacon, egg, and cheese for just about every day in the summer, they never get old. They are absolutely delicious everyday and every one of my friends who come here as well and get other items on the menu say the same. The food here is delicious and Bobby and Sandy are some of the nicest people you could meet. Everything is priced very well and comes out quick as well. Must visit if in Bayport.“
“Ok. Pretty much the best deli I’ve been to in all my time on Long Island. Their online ordering is a breeze and picking up almost as easy. Their large chopped salads are incredibly generous for the price. And their big specialty hero’s are insanely good, especially the Godson. Honorable mentions: Big Byron breakfast hero, Bronx Bomber breakfast hero, Texas Melt panini, Nicky Guns hero. Staff always amazingly nice and quick. Seriously, my favorite deli anywhere.“