12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Brocton

“We ordered Haddock Fish Baskets with fries, and every single thing about it was incredible and you can tell they care about their food. We both would recommend them to anyone, and we are definitely looking forward to ordering from there again soon!!!Also, I've seen a couple negative reviews on here, pay them absolutely zero mind.... literally being negative for the sake of being negative, probably never even ate there to begin with...worth every single cent and more!“

“Beautiful Day trip locale! There are several lil eateries and shops with local art or Bill's gear. The view is gorgeous and even though parking is limited, we found a spot easily. We had an energy fruit drink at the bakery which we loved, got the mini donuts too they were tasty but a little tough. Also tried the pizza which was really good, except the sauce is sweet, but the crust was delightful and the slices are huuuuggggge. The souvenir shops were absolutely wonderful and both owners were extremely kind and friendly. Finally, we got a couple frozen drinks from the Irish pub, very cool hangout with a unique fun vibe and decor. Overall, we had a fantastic time and will absolutely be back for a mini day vacay!“

“We got dinner here last night for the first time, and it was delicious!! We got a pepperoni pizza and boneless wings with the honey mustard sauce. The pizza was thick, fluffy, and flavorful, and the boneless wings were nice and crispy - and the sauce was super good. Will definitely come back next time we’re in the area!“

“We had a phone in order which was ready on time and the staff was very courteous. The pizza crust was light and fluffy with the right amount of crunch. All of the ingredients tasted high quality and hit the spot! We also had the hot wings were which had just the right amount of heat and the honey mustard was to die for! They were a bit skimpy on the celery and there were no carrots. Not a biggie to us but I know that matters to others.“

“Had a slice of pizza the other day and the pepperoni was so good. And had the breakfast sandwiches this morning it’s a really good deal you can get two for $7, and they are cooked fresh and with love! Would highly recommend it over Tim Hortons or McDonald’s I can’t wait to try the subs for lunch now!“

“This place is decent for a quick bite. I ordered chicken fingers, med sauce. They took me by surprise with the sauce but I was pleasantly delighted. They use a bbq base sauce. If that’s not your style order the regular buffalo sauce!! The single order also did not come with fries. $16 is a little much for just 5 and BC and Celery. Not bashing at all, I guess I should’ve read the menu better… all in all the other food I’m sure is great and I would come back!“

“Ordered Tuesday buy one get one pizza today but did not have a Crosbys card so day manager said that if I sign up for one on my phone she would reimburse me the difference. I went home and registered for a card and went back to the store this evening and sure enough my money was given back to me. Manager and staff today and this evening were very pleasant and helpful. Thankyou to all ! I appreciate everyone and their kindness.“

“So many things to like! First off, they have a lot on their menu to choose from. We tried their pizza, subs, fries, and salads. All of them were outstanding! They were also amazingly friendly and kind. I mentioned we were staying at a nearby Airbnb and didn't have any condiments. They gave us more than enough with a big smile on their face! We are SO happy we chose to do pickup here!!“

“So many things to like! First off, they have a lot on their menu to choose from. We tried their pizza, subs, fries, and salads. All of them were outstanding! They were also amazingly friendly and kind. I mentioned we were staying at a nearby Airbnb and didn't have any condiments. They gave us more than enough with a big smile on their face! We are SO happy we chose to do pickup here!!“

“Pizza was delicious the views of the lake were great. Was busy with orders for the eclipse that day, however service was great, even though it was busy. Very few places have the staff that could work under pressure and perform great. Will visit in the future.“

“The fredonia Mary's is a sight for Sore Eyes, but that doesn't matter because the food there is good.It is probably my favorite pizza in the Fredonia Dunkirk area.Typically it's just one man in the kitchen making everyone's food. He is alway polite whenever I pick up my food.There really isn't much else to say. Good pizza is good pizza.“

“Three of us were visiting from PA for the day. We went to a place that was reservations only or a corner table. The second place was an environment I did not care for, and this was the third choice. We were quickly convinced we were going to enjoy this place!My two friends enjoyed the wine! The food was excellent, and the service personal and attentive. We enjoyed our table being near the front, with an open front ! We would go there again with no question“