13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fredonia

“Best pizza ever. Everytime I'm in town I order and usually take one back home with me to Central N.Y. If you've had a bad experience, remember everyone makes mistakes or could have a bad day. Be glad you can at least get a good pizza there, it all sucks out here. Thank You Mary's in Fredonia, I always look forward to coming there when I'm in town.“

“Good stuff right here, the Fredonia location is the best.“

“Love this place when I’ve been drinking, one night I flipped a car and broke a telephone pole and ran from the cops for 3 hours and got severe frostbite just to get a Macalo calzone from DP dough and they were closed due to the weather and extreme temperature.“

“We had a phone in order which was ready on time and the staff was very courteous. The pizza crust was light and fluffy with the right amount of crunch. All of the ingredients tasted high quality and hit the spot! We also had the hot wings were which had just the right amount of heat and the honey mustard was to die for! They were a bit skimpy on the celery and there were no carrots. Not a biggie to us but I know that matters to others.“

“Finally a gluten free pizza that’s doughy and DELICIOUS! Dining in or taking out our food and service is always fantastic!! I have celiac disease but I have eaten here several times safely!“

“There is only two gift shops and the rest are pubs and restaurants, but it sure is beautiful! And the shops are very cute. One of them has Dunkirk souvenirs, and the other had homemade stuff like soap, and sailboats made out of drift wood. It was a beach themed shop. It was all very cute!
The view was phenominal.“

“Great Food ,!“

“Favorite place to get chicken fingers! They’re great plain, and I love the honey mustard and the mild bbq sauces.“

“Best pizza and wings in the area now !! If you haven’t tried it you’re missing out !!“

“Stopped in for a Mother’s Day celebration for lunch a day early because everywhere is a mad house on Mother’s Day. Jen was our server and she was wonderful beyond words. The food came out quick and hot. It was delicious! Their menu was awesome- we will definitely be back because there’s so much more to try!“

“Ordered Tuesday buy one get one pizza today but did not have a Crosbys card so day manager said that if I sign up for one on my phone she would reimburse me the difference. I went home and registered for a card and went back to the store this evening and sure enough my money was given back to me. Manager and staff today and this evening were very pleasant and helpful. Thankyou to all ! I appreciate everyone and their kindness.“

“My partner & I traveled to Lily Dale for the 4th of July & had a fantastic experience at the Lily Cafe & Restaurant! The atmosphere was welcoming & unique.

I ordered the Lily Dale Salad, which was one of the BEST salads I’ve ever had. We also shared both the apple pie sundae & the s’mores sundae, again—both were easily among the best sundaes I have ever had.

The service was warm, friendly, & quick. Would absolutely recommend the Lily Cafe & Restaurant to anyone visiting Lily Dale & will definitely be back during our next visit! 💕“

“Super amazing staff! Thanks.“