32 Best Pizza Restaurants near Port Colborne

1 The Lock Wood Fired Pizza

4.7 Superb 401 Reviews

182 West Street, Port Colborne

• Take-Out

“This was our first time at the lock, some friends suggested we try their pizza. First of all the air conditioner was so high it felt like it was going to snow. The service was slow but friendly, to be fair it was quite busy and so we felt that was a good sign about the food. We ordered 3 pizzas and we'd rate the pizza a 6/10. Most likely won't go back. Gave 4 stars for overall rating because our server was sweet but gave service a 3 because while we were eating our food that took 45 minutes, there was another server who was stacking chairs and spraying tables, not the best atmosphere to eat in.”

2 Owl Pizza, PORT COLBORNE

4.5 Superb 93 Reviews

398 Main Street West, Port Colborne

• Delivery

“They are the nicest people. Super high quality ingredients.”

3 Christopher's Pizza

4.3 Superb 161 Reviews

94 Killaly Street West, Port Colborne

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband and I ordered large meat lovers pizza and 30 mild wing today for lunch. Everything was absolutely delicious! My husband and I have found out new pizza place.”

4 Domino's Pizza

4.3 Superb 108 Reviews

244 Killaly Street West Suite 15, Port Colborne

• Delivery

“we ordered the combo 1 2 3, 2 pizzas and a cheese bread, and lava cake for dessert...thank you sooo much. it was delicious, and the phone call to order the young lady was great. and the delivery guy was great also...delivering was fast, mmmmmmmm!!!!!!!! thank you very much for a very hot delicious supper 😀👍💖.......... Beatrice”

5 Pizza Pizza

3.9 Good 97 Reviews

154 Main Street West, Port Colborne

• Delivery

“It's the only Pizza Pizza location I order from. I don't know what they do differently from the others but after years of ordering pizza's from different locations and different places I get my pizzas from. Unfortunately I'm not in Port Colburne as often as I would like to have a pizza as it's a 25 minute drive from home.”

6 Nino Pizza Port Colborne

3.8 Good 74 Reviews

474 Main Street West, Port Colborne

• Delivery

“Great pizza, friendly service. Ordered many times never had a issue!”

7 Super Mario's Pizza

3.8 Good 190 Reviews

281 King Street, Port Colborne

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They hosted our party for my wife's birthday and were incredibly accommodating. The food was fantastic and everyone had an awesome time.”

8 Pizza Hut

3.6 Good 81 Reviews

Unit C, 111 Clarence Street Unit D, Port Colborne

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“What an amazing pizza place near Nickle Beach. Came for a beach day with bunch of my friends/family and being vegetarian gives us only few options but after finding Pizza Hut made our day. Placed order over a call for 4+ pizza, Pepsi etc and the person on the call(Mital) was such a lovely person, she not only did help us choose good deal for our option and she was patient and friendly. She provided plenty napkins, spare box etc. to help us out. I would definitely going back when I am in the area. Great job 👏 love your passion!”

9 The spot bar

4.0 Good 126 Reviews

225 Main Street West, Port Colborne

• Delivery

“Best spot in town! foods great and beer is always cold!”

10 Red Swan Pizza - Welland

4.5 Superb 268 Reviews

Next to Dollar Tree, 200 Fitch Street Suite 19, Welland · 7.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great spot! thanks for supporting local baseball teams!”

11 For Pizza's Sake

4.4 Superb 282 Reviews

233 Broadway, Welland · 6.22 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“great pizza great wings and amazing staff. 10/10 definitely check it out for yourself!!!!”

12 Domino's Pizza

4.4 Superb 212 Reviews

440 Niagara Street, Welland · 8.17 miles

• Delivery

“I can't believe that in 10 years of impeccable, unmatched service, I've never contributed a review. Don't let the sign above the door fool you. These people are pizza artisans. I don't even know what I could say to do justice to their craft. And I don't mean for fast food standards. Go to an Italian restaurant and pay $25 for a pizza, 50% chance you get a lazy slop pie. $10 here and you will consistently get the most perfect, prepared-with-love and appetizing meal. Love you guys thank you for always being there”

13 Pazzo's Pizzeria (Wainfleet Location)

4.6 Superb 96 Reviews

42114 ON-3, Wainfleet · 7.63 miles

• Delivery

“Great pizza, friendly staff, A+++”

14 The Brick Oven Pizza Company

4.5 Superb 126 Reviews

7600 Durliat Road, Welland · 8.44 miles

• Delivery

“Had a couple of their beauties yesterday. The idea was to have a nibble on the way home and finish AT home - sons of b's were so fantastic we barely made it out of the lot before launching into the rest! Awesome job guys, we'll be back! we had the meat lovers and the margherita #sogood”

15 Rose City Pizza

4.2 Good 279 Reviews

473 Thorold Road, Welland · 8.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just happened to be in the area and dropped in for a bite. I have to say the pizza was amazing.”

16 Luciano's Pizzeria Welland Ontario

4.2 Good 231 Reviews

123 Southworth Street North, Welland · 6.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Pizza is fabulous. Ingredients are clearly the best quality. The pizza reminds me of pizza from La Hacienda in Niagara Falls New York. If you have been to the Hacienda you know exactly what I mean the best pizza fresh quality ingredients like Lucianos. I very highly recommend this 🍕. Thank you for reading my post.”

17 Bridgewater Brewery

4.6 Superb 208 Reviews

60 Niagara Street, Welland · 7.44 miles

“We had a lovely date dinner in this quaint, modern, family-friendly brewery. They were nearly fully reserved; unfortunately, the tables available were not appropriate. When I pointed out I could not sit in the sun or at a high top, they willingly made adjustments. Our hostess, waitress, bussers, and management were all attentive, kind, and generally lovely. The food was wonderful; from the appetizers we enjoyed were Warm Butter Pretzel - BRUSHED WITH BUTTER AND SALTED, PICKLES, GRAINY MUSTARD, HOUSE-BREWED BEER AND CHEESE QUESO SAUCE, and Lobster Dip - LOBSTER MEAT IN A CREAMY DIP, BUBBLY MOZZARELLA WITH WARM PITA. Our mains were Burgers and fries - CLASSIC – CHEDDAR, LETTUCE, ONION, PICKLE, GARLIC MAYO, as well as the Steak and frites - 10 OZ NY STRIPLOIN, COMPOUND BUTTER, GREMOLATA, SERVED WITH HOUSE-CUT FRIES. Dessert we tried Fruit Cobbler with Ice Cream - FRESH SEASONAL FRUIT TOPPED WITH LIGHT AND CRISPY COBBLER, SERVED WITH LEMON WHIPPED CREAM, and Crème Brûlée - SILKY CUSTARD BOTTOM, SWEET CRUNCHY TOP. The meal was delicious. An excellent experience; my only tweak is I wish the fries had been fresher. The Bridgewater Brewery had such a great environment. Well worth the trip to Welland. We were also informed they had a dog-friendly patio at the rear, making this a must for a return visit for our family. The kitchens were impeccable. Bathroom was ADODA compliant. Staff were accommodating Parking available at rear but stairs from rear Accessible from front”

18 Gino's Pizza

4.2 Good 96 Reviews

800 Niagara Street, Welland · 9.03 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We have made Gino’s our Friday night “go-to” because the food is CONSISTENTLY high quality, hot, delicious. But most of all, we enjoy the outstanding service that the staff at this location provide. Travis is usually at the counter when we come in or answers the phone to take orders. He is always friendly, kind and even during the busiest times he treats all customers well. He is the reason we come back week to week!”

19 Vincent's Pizzeria

4.1 Good 228 Reviews

324 Thorold Road, Welland · 8.25 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Epic pizza”

20 Antonios Pizzeria

4.1 Good 144 Reviews

95 Lincoln Street, Welland · 6.81 miles

“Hands down best pizza in Welland. Delicious every time! Great customer service, always friendly on the other end of the phone when ordering and when picking up. Competitive prices.”

21 Shawarma House

4.4 Superb 383 Reviews

824 East Main Street, Welland · 7.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“By far the best food I've ever had! The Dubai chocolate cup is life changing, the best thing I've ever put in my mouth! The staff are amazing, so friendly. This place is by far the best hidden Gem! 10/10 recommend!”

22 Ever Fresh Pizza

4.0 Good 116 Reviews

301 Thorold Road, Welland · 8.23 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great pizza and excellent customer service! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked, with generous toppings and a great crust. What really stood out was the customer service—staff were friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was handled smoothly. The overall experience was pleasant and welcoming. I would definitely recommend this place and will be coming back again.”

23 Wings Block

4.4 Superb 189 Reviews

515 King Street, Welland · 6.56 miles

• Delivery

“The Hidden Gem of Welland. We have been going to the Wings Block on King St for over a year now and have never been disappointed. Just got home from a late lunch there. Everything we ordered came beautifully presented, all of our food was fresh and tasted great. Our server Roxanne rounded out a great afternoon. Always smiling and happy and makes sure that we always leave on a positive note. So, if you are looking for somewhere new in Welland for great food, great service and great value, the Wings Block is for you. You'll wish you would have found it earlier....”

24 Pizza Hut Welland

3.9 Good 327 Reviews

897 Niagara Street, Welland · 9.35 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Anand at Welland location delivered exceptional customer service with a genuine smile, welcoming attitude, and great attention to detail. He was friendly, professional, efficient, and made the entire dining experience truly enjoyable and memorable.”

25 Tailgates Bar & Grill

4.1 Good 258 Reviews

200 Fitch Street, Welland · 7.65 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Well, we drove from N Falls to Welland to try this outstanding pizza and wings. It was outstanding ! Pizza used cup & char pepperoni done to perfection and dough was fabulous. Chicken wings were huge and reminded us of Buffalo wings 20 years ago in Buffalo. No bruises on these wings A1 quality . They actual use butter and hot sauce for the type of wings we chose. Worth the drive and excellent price , staff was amazing .Ryan & Tracey got his down to a science . We'll be back”

26 Little Caesars Pizza

3.5 Good 97 Reviews

572 Niagara Street, Welland · 8.38 miles

• Delivery

“I was in there around noon today to pick up a mobile order - except my dumb ass didn't pay close enough attention to the location I was ordering from when I finished off on the app. I didn't realize I had messed up until the gentleman working here informed me he didn't have any order in the queue. Rather than send me on my way - which would have made me late to a meeting - he told me not to worry that he would make my order for me. He even contacted the place where I had ordered on the app, confirmed payment, and got everything sorted in the five minutes it took for my Italian cheese bread to be ready. He was unbelievably helpful and courteous and my order was fresh and delicious. 10/10 service - they're lucky to have that dude! What a rockstar!”

27 Twice The Deal Pizza

3.7 Good 206 Reviews

30 Rice Road, Welland · 8.29 miles

• Delivery

“I really enjoy there great quality pizza Always tastes amazing with affordable prices”

28 Little Caesars Pizza

3.3 Good 86 Reviews

390 Lincoln Street, Welland · 6.94 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I came into Little Caesars to fix an issue with a previous order, and Rayden went above and beyond to help me. She was incredibly kind, patient, and made my food fresh for me without hesitation. She truly turned the whole experience around and made it extra special. Amazing customer service—thank you so much, Rayden!”

29 The Kavern

3.6 Good 65 Reviews

190 Maple Ave, Welland · 7.22 miles

• Delivery

“Excellent food and serviceUpdate March 23 2004New owner have done a great job cleaning up the bar and the food was great! I hear good things are on the way. Looking forward to seeing what they can do with this location! Best of luck to them”

30 Pizza Pizza

3.4 Good 282 Reviews

800 Niagara Street, Welland · 8.97 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love coming to this Pizza Pizza! I’m a grad school student and the manager has such a great memory and is so kind. He always asks me how school is going. AND he remembers my order! The tables are always clean, and I sit and read at them while I eat so that matters to me! My pizza is always hot and tastes great and I never have to wait long! I would highly recommend it here!”

31 Boston Pizza

3.4 Good 363 Reviews

934 Niagara Street, Welland · 9.44 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Last Monday, we had placed an order, around 8 pm. Not long after, we found ourselves with two flat tires .. waiting for a tow truck. We let Boston Pizza know we'd be late. It wound up being two hours before the tow truck arrived! A cab took us to Boston Pizza, at now after 11! They had closed the kitchen. One of the mangers, Rosie, who was so pleasant!, had them open the kitchen, and they recooked our order!!! Thank you Rosie!!!!”

32 Volcano Pizzeria

3.3 Good 218 Reviews

256 East Main Street, Welland · 7.49 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Hello all you disappointed pizza lovers. I have been a loyal Volcanoes customer for 25+ yrs. If you are seeking that awesome tasting pizza from Volcanoes you were used to. Order weekdays after 4.00pm and Sundays all day. That is the time when Jerry the main owner is overseeing the restaurant. The other minority owner Chris, has turned into a miserable piece of s*** that will not make your pizza with thick crust and has really started skimping on all toppings, thats if he even puts the right toppings you ordered. He,s gotten ignorant as f#ck over the years and seems to be taking his miserableness out on customers. Needs to put a diaper on and retire. So in conclusion, try ordering during the hours I mentioned and you will be pleasantly surprised with your pizza tasting just as good as it did years ago. Oh and if you want to step up your flavour experience, ask for spicey pepperoni (cup&char). You wont regret it. Cheers and good eating.”