50 Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Catharines

“Just plain old fashioned amazing pizza. My kid and I are pizza snobs. We could not have been happier than to have found this restaurant!! Try it!“

“Delicious, meaty wings with best hot sauce ever! Ordered the Serous and Mango Hab. Courteous service, excellent food!“

“😀Food was terrific and serice fast freindly“

“Great spot! thanks for supporting local baseball teams!“

“ordered from here from uber on a whim. Expectations weren't that high. But wow were we pleasantly surprised! Pizza was cheesey and tasted great. Cajun fries were crispy and nicely seasoned. Will definitely order from here again!“

“We are from ohio ...in town visiting a friend ...ordered a steak sub and a veal parm sub ...if the bread isn't made in house id be very surprised...delicious...both subs were great....ordered at 8:30 on a weds ..owner said to not wait long to come get it ....I arrived about 10 till 9 it was being wrapped up while I waited ...owner is very particular about the product he serves and ,I believe, quite proud of his work ....im posting immediately after eating......Bravo sir ...we will be back for pizza next time“

“I have had the privilege of eating the best steak here in St. Catharines and also work with empowering people, NGA2 not only offers good and hearty meals but also warms the heart at a personal level which motivates excellence in all fields regarding the restaurant business. Last but not least, this destination is more of a family dining area than a regular eatery and leave spot. Come one come all and enjoy this experience firsthand.“

“Best pizza we've had lately! This place has truly become our go-to spot. The crust is out of this world crispy yet soft, and the toppings are always fresh. The Paneer Pizza with Ancho Chipotle base is absolutely fantastic! The smoky heat from the chipotle pairs perfectly with the creamy, rich paneer. Every bite is a delight. Highly recommend it“

“Great dinner! Awesome flavors!! People here are amazing!! Love, Love!!“

“This is a hidden gem! It is a small place that you could easily miss. The pizza is fabulous! Nicely done crust, never greasy, not dripping with sauce. All of the toppings are fresh and flavourful. The owner is very friendly. This place is definitely worth trying...again and again!“

“The pizza and sandwiches at Pizza Pizza are absolutely delicious!

The pizza is always fresh, with a perfectly baked crust and generous toppings that make every bite flavorful and satisfying. The cheese melts just right, and the ingredients taste high quality.

Their sandwiches are just as impressive — warm, well-filled, and packed with flavor. The bread is soft yet slightly crispy, and everything tastes fresh and well-prepared.

If you're looking for tasty pizza and satisfying sandwiches, this is definitely a great choice!“

“It’s servers like Sophia that make us wanna come back. Friendly, great service and mentioned to us about CAA discount. Were frequent customers and she’s the first server that’s mentioned it. Kudos Sophia“

“Wonderful dinner experience, great food and service!“

“The best pizza in town!“

“Ordered from Domino's today morning and wow, they nailed it. The pizza was very good – hot, cheesy, with that perfect crispy-yet-chewy crust, fresh toppings, and just the right amount of sauce. I went for a classic pepperoni with extra cheese, and it tasted way better than expected. Seriously, one of the best chain pizzas I've had in a while.
Delivery was super fast – ordered around 11 AM and it arrived in under 25 minutes, piping hot and perfectly packed. The driver was friendly too. Great job, team! This hit the spot on a busy evening. Will definitely order again soon.“

“nice atmosphere and the waitress tina is very good with her customers“

“Best pizza around, fantastic“

“IDK why some comments are rude. I've been going here for 7 years the owner is very nice and the service is wonderful there is nothing I'd change with the atmosphere terrific pizza terrific owner terrific restaurant“

“Pizza is great! Owners are amazing people who give back to the community. Come and support their business 😊“

“I ordered online so I cannot rate the atmosphere and service. I can rate the food upon delivery which was cold. I mean, I don't know what, did he drive all over the city before he brought it to me? I don't know what but it was ice cold and the drinks were warm so I don't know. I put the pizza in the toaster oven for I don't know how long now maybe 5-10 minutes and that was good enough which then made it delicious. I don't expect to have delivery delivered ice cold and warm. One of the pops didn't have any fizz. Which made it taste like just sugar. So ice cold pizza and no fizz in the pop and I'm still giving you four stars.

Also, what happened to your two for one? Your name says it all, Twice the Deal Pizza. I certainly did not get that. Two medium pizzas and two bottles of root beer cost just shy of $60 which is insane!“

“the food was exactly as ordered and arrived quickly. One of the staff called because one of the pops I ordered and she asked if I wanted a substitution and, if so, which one. That was very much appreciated. I had also requested that the delivery person knock loudly and leave the order on the chair on the front step. This was done as requested, as well.“

“probably the nicest bar tenders I've ever met ... very clean bar“

“Best pizza & wings in Niagara region, perfect place for chill beer 🍻 & wine 🍷.highly recommend this place.“

“Fantastic place to enjoy a delicious meal. Cafe Amore has now risen to the top of my list of favourite restaurants. The first time I was there it was a summer dinner outside. I experienced the Black and Blue pasta. Simply delectable. Last night we returned for an early Valentine’s Day dinner. This time I could not resist the Steak Gorgonzola. So incredibly decadent, so delicious. My wife had the Penne Alfredo with Lobster and Crab. Also a beautifully presented dish that was delicious. The Caesar salad is definitely worth the upgrade too. Cozy and warm dining experience with a great staff. We are looking forward to coming back soon. There’s just too many delicious options on that menu. See you soon!“

“I had Jerry’s Pizza for the first time tonight and I really don’t know what is up with people with these pizza reviews. Great price, great food. Pizza was nice and light loaded with fresh cheese and pepperoni. If you’re stopping in the area and want some yummy pizza I highly recommend Jerry’s. Support local, cheers“

“Vegan pizza at its best! Great food and great price! Well done!“

“On the Marc pizza is the best pizza in the region and especially when Stephen Sherk makes it he's the bomb keep up the good work guys“

“Excellent tasting food served fresh and hot with the lowest prices in the Niagara region. There are no big screen tvs or a dining room, as they only offer pick up or delivery. Employees are very friendly and quick at getting your food ready as soon as it is ordered.“

“We went for my birthday yesterday and the staff, food and atmosphere were top notch! We were so impressed with the impeccable service and cuisine! Thank you to all the staff for making our dining experience very special! Highly recommended!“

“This is a hidden gem! It is a small place that you could easily miss. The pizza is fabulous! Nicely done crust, never greasy, not dripping with sauce. All of the toppings are fresh and flavourful. The owner is very friendly. This place is definitely worth trying...again and again!“

“As a vegetarian, finding a genuinely good veggie pizza is surprisingly hard. Sounds simple, right?! Well… apparently not! 😂

This loaded veggie pizza was an absolute medley of flavours. The onions were perfectly, sweet, well roasted and caramelized and the peppers complemented them SO well. Every topping had its place, and every bite was delicious!

You must try this place. You definitely won’t regret going… but you will regret NOT going! 🙃“

“Haven’t had Pie Guys in ages, ordered their Thursday wing special & a personal pie off their website, and everything was SO delicious! Perfect pizza & the wings were as amazing as I remembered 😋 I ordered super saucy and I got super saucy….AND we got 9 wings for each lb, I guess because they were a bit smaller than usual they increased the quantity to still give us a lb….I love this! Awesome job, Pie Guys Linwell 🤩🤍“

“after trying several different pizza joints around st catharines we came across Pete's... and has been our go to ever since. their pizza is always delicious, quick delivery and priced fairly.“

“Did not have a good experience this evening. Called and ordered a steak sub. Pick it up and brought it home only 5mins away and the sub was so soggy I couldn’t eat it. Called & the person working offered to make a new sub. Went and switched out the subs and got a sub that was the exact same. This place use to be so good! Bin going here for over 18years. Not sure if it has changed hands but we will not be returning.“

“The pizza here is very consistently delicious the kids love the cheese pizza and the wife and I are more then happy with their specialty pizzas specifically the Shawarma pizza, the butter chicken, and the tandoori. Great service and great taste.“

“awesome food and great staff.“

“Had the Florentine pizza! ..creamy garlic base, spinach & mushrooms.... crispy, thin crust. One of the most delicious, delectable, scrumptious, tasty pizzas I have ever had in my life! The only thing that would top that would be to be having that same pizza in an Italian village cafe in Florence. Thank you so much to the kind gentleman who made my delightful pizza! And God who has given me tastebuds and the means to enjoy such a treat!“

“We returned to a family favourite after 30 years to find the food and service as incredible as always. Authentic and extremely delicious food, fantastic service and we left happy and full! Thank you to our wonderful server, grandson of original Big Marco for looking after us so very well. Highly recommend the pizzas, panzerotti, manicotti and anything that comes with their delicious pasta sauce!“

“Absolutely amazing pizza from Pizza Pizza Glendale! Ordered the pizza per inch with double olives and double pepperoni and they did not disappoint. Loaded with toppings, perfectly cooked crust, and great flavour in every bite. The pepperoni was generous and the extra olives made it even better. Fresh, hot, and delicious — definitely one of the best orders I’ve had from here. Highly recommend!“

“Love this place and it's so convenient...Lots of parking, food is good and service is too.“

“This is my new place to get pizza and wings. Delicious.“

“Finally got back inside after the hubbub of all the worldly things and was very happy with our food and the service. Ordered the Chicken Sandwich (Spicy) with fries and the BBLT with house salad. (Fries *and* salad are for sharing!) Both meals tasty, hot and the fries, I must say, were perfect. Although not such a great list of beers on tap, the Oast Barn Raiser is a reliable choice and available. Prices are good and with inflation recently hurting everyone and everything, I think the value for money is quite good. Planning to be back again!“

“I'm going to review this pizza place with my 5 senses. Smell: This pizza place smelled fantastic from outside, the pizza I ordered was no different. Sound: The older gentleman who took my order clearly had no time for the slightest small talk, but it did seem like it was just starting to get busy. Abrupt, but not rude. Sight: A little disappointing. The cheese and toppings moved to one side a little bit, like someone dropped the pizza. Taste: Excellent. Touch: Texture was great. Perfectly cooked. 4/5“

“I cannot say enough how great this pizza is. The kind staff is made even better with Abob. You bring a smile to my face when I see you working those early shifts. Thank you for the special care and attention to my order and the energy you bring to brighten up the space. A reasonable price for fantastic food. Good crust and even sauce with no chunks. 5 stars every time!“

“it was my first time trying dominos and omg im in love! i got the medium parm stuffed crust pizza w their cheesy bread and choco lava cake to end the night w some sweet deliciousness and oh my god! i am so impressed! youve earned yourself a new customer! thank u so so much for ur excellent and prompt service!“

“Thank you :)

Denis Morris’s Reach Team was ordering Pizza and the staff at Gino’s pizza were super kind and helpful while helping the team order a couple of pizza’s for the end of season pizza party. The pizza was great and everyone was super happy with it. On behalf of DM’s Reach Team we are very grateful for the assistance and patience that the staff at Gino’s pizza had with us as we were ordering the pizza. We will definitely be coming back to Gino’s for more pizza!“

“PIzza was hot, fresh, and full of flavour, and the staff were friendly and attentive throughout my visit. It’s clear they care about quality and customer satisfaction. Whether I’m grabbing a slice or picking up a whole pie, this place never disappoints. I’ll definitely be coming back again!“

“This place doesn't get credit for how busy it is or that it's a fast food place. People rate harshly for miner issues. Obviously They have never worked in this environment. I get it, things get messed up, happens to every business. What sets this one apart is that they actually go out of their way to fix it! They forgot cheese on my breadsticks and send another order. This costs them money. They answered the phone, and were kind and helpful. Even wrote sorry on the box. In the end we got our breadsticks and they also offered a credit first.
For all this 5 stars. Food was hot, perfect and customer service was great! Thanks again!“

“Great wings & pizza at this spot, but everything I've had from their kitchen has been tasty. They have 40 different flavors of chicken wings & 40 different flavors of pizza. What I love is they automatically bring you blue cheese with carrots & celery when you order wings, unlike many places nowadays... Fave Wings: plain with salt & pepper! Fave Pizza: The C-B-R pizza - pizza sauce, mozzarella, chicken, bacon, ranch, tomatoes & mushrooms. The staff is friendly, and it's usually a fun, local atmosphere. Bands often come in on the weekends, and you can be sure that "the big game" will be on their big screen TV.“

“in my opinion the best pizza to have. Consistently fantastic food. Love the "Quad". Wings and subs are delicious. Also great owners and staff...“