15 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Catharines

1
Valley

Valley Italian • $$
93 Arthur St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi Gorgonzola and Spaghetti with Meatballs
House Lasagne and Spaghetti and Meatballs
Roasted Garlic Bread with Cheese
Cinghiale Ragu on Pappardelle
Bruschetta and Cesar Salad
Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Parmesan Pasta
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Lemoncello Cheesecake
Raspberry Sorbet

“We had the pleasure of experiencing an unforgettable Italian feast at Valley Restaurant in St. Catherine! Their commitment to quality and service shines through every bite, making each dish truly divine. Their kindness and attention to detail served as a reminder as to how hospitality and culinary excellence should look. 5/5“

4.7 Superb443 Reviews
Italian Cafe Cafe • $
88 Facer St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli by the Dozen
Charcuterie Board
Assorted Cannolis
Veal Parmigiana
Coffee Flight
Grilled Veggie
Cannoli Pie
Iced Latte
Veal Parm
Gelato

“The restaurant and Carrie are so welcoming. I had a chocolate gelato while waiting for my freshly made panini. It was delicious and such a lovely treat on this hot day. I also had a delicious hazelnut iced latte. Then I had the most delicious veal parm panini, with extra sauce for dipping. I'd have drank the rest of the sauce if I was home alone! I finally got to try one of their delicious canolis too.“

4.7 Superb67 Reviews
Johnny Rocco's Italian Grill Italian • $$
271 Merritt St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Nonna’S Smashed Meatball
Italian Wedding Soup
Baked Chicken Penne
Zia’S Rice Balls
Eggplant Parmesan
Mushroom Ravioli
Chicken Parmesan
Goat Cheese Dip
Johnny Rocco’S
Lobster Ravioli

“We booked the Barrel Room for my Dad's 80th Birthday. Janine was easy to work with, and our servers were incredibly helpful. The guests commented on how much they loved the atmosphere of the room - but the food took centre stage! Personally, I highly recommend the mushroom ravioli in the rose sauce. Mmmm.“

4.4 Superb111 Reviews
Cafe Amore Mediterranean • $$
211 Martindale Rd, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Chicken Garden Salad
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Crab and Shrimp Pasta
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Chicken Gorgonzola
Steak Gorgonzola
Margherita Pizza
Mushroom Ravioli
Fried Provolone

“Fantastic place to enjoy a delicious meal. Cafe Amore has now risen to the top of my list of favourite restaurants. The first time I was there it was a summer dinner outside. I experienced the Black and Blue pasta. Simply delectable. Last night we returned for an early Valentine’s Day dinner. This time I could not resist the Steak Gorgonzola. So incredibly decadent, so delicious. My wife had the Penne Alfredo with Lobster and Crab. Also a beautifully presented dish that was delicious. The Caesar salad is definitely worth the upgrade too. Cozy and warm dining experience with a great staff. We are looking forward to coming back soon. There’s just too many delicious options on that menu. See you soon!“

4.3 Superb336 Reviews
Coppola's Ristorante & Banquet Facility Italian • $$
203 Carlton St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Cake and Ice Cream Cake
Roast Beef and Checken
Eggplant Parmigiana
Gnocchi Piemontese
Linguine Bolognese
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmesan
Sicilian Cannoli
Agnello Al Forno
Chicken Focaccia

“The food was pretty good. The Ceasar salad was incredible. The service was not great. We felt pressured the moment we sat down to order the "Date Night" special. When we didn't order that or alcohol, the waitress got real snooty. Wouldn't recommend it.“

4.4 Superb89 Reviews
The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen Italian • $$
1 Lock St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Twisted Spaghetti Meatballs
Twisted Sausage Pizza
Twisted Gnocchi 2 0
Gnocchi Gorgonzola
Charcuterie Board
Margherita Pizza
Smoked Duck Pizza
Antipasto Board
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Supreme

“We had the pleasure of experiencing the food here last night. Did the take out. And after a half hour drive home..the entire meal was still PERFECT!! And the amount you get is quite a bit to boot. Delicous!!! This is a must try if in Port Dalhousie. Wow!! “

4.3 Superb133 Reviews
Mele Trattoria Italian • $$
26 Church St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Gnocchi with Homemade Sauce
House Made Meatballs
Pollo Primavera
Warm Olives
Prosciutto

“This is my new favourite Italian. So intimate and the loveliest, loveliest people. When we were there the usual server was on vacation so we had the pleasure of a sister of the chef. There were three siblings between the kitchen and serving and all seemed so lovely. The pasta was the freshest I’ve ever had and the pasta sauce was incredible. We were a party of four and we all walked out so incredibly happy with the people and the food. I can’t wait to go back.“

4.7 Superb19 Reviews
Deluca Fine Foods St. Catharines Italian • $$
134 Hartzel Rd, St. Catharines

“We tried it out and it was really good. I can't eat other brands from the supermarket as it's poor quality and usually has an after taste. I wowed a Toronto couple with the lasagna which was accompanied with ACE bread and of course, mixed salad. The Toronto couple bought the lasagna and brought back with them.“

4.9 Superb10 Reviews
Lina Linguini's Pasta & Grille Italian • $$
Ridley Square, 111 Fourth Ave, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Baked Asiago & Artichoke Dip
Roasted Walnut Gnocchi
Spaghetti Meatballs
Spaghetti Marinara
Side Caesar Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Carbonara
Cheesecake Slice
House Salad
Tiramisu

“This has easily been one of my all time favourite restaurants for over a decade now and I’ve always had a great experience. Unfortunately last night, I ordered the chicken Alfredo and this was the only time I have ever had any issues, as I didn’t make it out of the restaurant before getting sick. While I’m unsure if it was my chicken or the heavier amount of sauce, I still mentioned it to our server as embarrassed as I felt. I assured her that I wasn’t upset and it wasn’t her fault. Things happen sometimes and it’s not enough to turn me off from this place because of one experience (which thankfully I recovered from in a couple of hours). She apologized and offered to remove the dish from our bill, which although I told her I wasn’t expecting as I still consumed it and would have paid for it, she ultimately stressed that she just wanted me to feel better. I don’t remember her name but I am very appreciative of her understanding and kindness, so if by chance she sees this, I wanted to say thank you.“

4.2 Good75 Reviews
Fresco's Euro Grille Italian • $$
Ridley Heights Plaza, 100 Fourth Ave, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Chicken Bacon Carbonara
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Chicken Asiago Quesadillas
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan
Crab Dumplings
Caesar Salad
Pizza Funghi
Steak Tacos
Fish Tacos

“We had a great dinner here. In fact we have had many great meals here. Staff are quick and attentive, food comes quick and cooked as requested. The atmosphere is nice and the restaurant is well taken care of. Prices are more than fair for the quality and portions, we send all of our friends and family here who haven’t been and all agree it’s great!“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Stromboli's Pizza Ltd Italian • $
86 Niagara St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Great Pizza
Wings

“I was surprised to see how much you get for your money. I dare to say that this xlarge pizza wieghs more then any 24 slice in the city. Ordered x cheese and I definitely got extra. The cheese and sauce are high quality. Wings were very good also!“

4.2 Good16 Reviews
Pizza Pizza Pizza • $
367 Lake St #2, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Classic Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Wings
Bacon Crumble
Large Pizza
Sauce

“We all know by now the Pizza Pizza taste. It’s a Canadian classic. This location had really great customer service and my pie was spicy and delicious. $29 for a large walk in special, three topping, three pops and dip. No complaints whatsoever. It was a perfect experience.“

4.1 Good39 Reviews
Pizza Pizza Pizza • $$
210 Glendale Ave, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Funnel Cake Stix with Caramel
Plant-Based Chicken Bites
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza
Popcorn Chicken
Chicken Wings
Panzerotti
Pizzas
Fries

“"210 Glendale Avenue Pizza Pizza is a hidden gem! From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with warmth and hospitality. The pizzas here are truly outstanding—fresh ingredients, perfectly baked crust, and generous toppings that satisfy even the most discerning pizza aficionados. What sets this location apart is its attention to detail and commitment to quality. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice on the go or indulging in a full pie with friends, you can always count on 210 Glendale Avenue Pizza Pizza to deliver an unforgettable dining experience. Don't miss out on this culinary delight!"“

4.1 Good76 Reviews
Industria Pizzeria + Bar Pizza • $$
221 Glendale Ave, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

NY Strip and Gralic Mashed Potatoes
Spinach and Artichoke Spinach Dip
Tagliatelle Al Fungi Selvaggi
Fried Calimari Shareable
Deconstructed Cheesecake
Chocolate Creme Brulee
Braised Beef Short Rib
Gnocci in Rose Sauce
Prosciutto E Rucola
The Industria Pizza

“This place is perfect but I have literally only 1 complaint, and this is why I only rated it 4 stars instead of 5: the bathroom doors NEED to be replaced. The food, service and atmosphere are outstanding, but the bathroom doors simply don’t work. I tried 3 different stalls and all 3 doors wouldn’t shut properly. Please fix this, but keep everything else the same! :)“

4.1 Good89 Reviews
IL FORNELLO - St. Catharines Italian • $$
300 Fourth Ave Unit 1 - Building C, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Pizza Gluten Free
Pizza Pasta Tuesdays
Vegan Penne Capri
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Plant Based Menu
Seafood Linguini
Mushroom Pizza
Gnocchi Asiago
Chicken Asiago

“I had an amazing experience on the patio of Il Fornello! We had pizza and drinks and the food was delicious, fresh, and authentic. Our server Sarah was amazing, attentive, and quick(extra points for being so fast on a hot day). I have passed this place a few times as it is in a plaza, but now I know it's there with a nice patio I will be back for sure!“

4.1 Good302 Reviews
Loading...
map Map