City Island Pizza Company
273 City Island Ave, Bronx
(718) 210-1970
Customers' Favorites
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Bar Size Margarita Pizza
Spaghetti Carbonara
Margherita Pizza
Rice Balls
Escargot
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
No Lie! Best Lobster Roll of my life.
I had just gotten back from Martha's Vineyard, spent time in Maine, and my boys go to school in Rhode Island. I'm no stranger to the warm butter sensation of knuckles on hot bread, but this roll blew me away. I would have never tried a Lobster roll from a pizza joint, but a long time City Island resident said that of all the big sign fish places on City Island, this was the best fish on the strip. I was skeptical, but...
I had just gotten back from Martha's Vineyard, spent time in Maine, and my boys go to school in Rhode Island. I'm no stranger to the warm butter sensation of knuckles on hot bread, but this roll blew me away. I would have never tried a Lobster roll from a pizza joint, but a long time City Island resident said that of all the big sign fish places on City Island, this was the best fish on the strip. I was skeptical, but...
i came here w my bf and his (italian) family on sunday and everyone LOVED the food. the clams appetizer was the best we have ever had. and i dream about the burrata sandwich. pesto was homemade and so much quality prosciutto i’ve only had a comparable sandwich in Florence. you can tell they really put effort into each dish, they were so flavorful and fresh and the server was so kind! gave us pineapple ice cream before we left. will 100 percent come back here.
You May Also Like
The Black Whale - 279 City Island Ave
![]()
American, New American
Clipper Coffee - 274 City Island Ave
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Patisserie/Cake Shop, Pet Friendly
Man Overboard Bar - 247 City Island Ave
![]()
Bar, Sports Bar, American, Vegetarian
Vegetarian options: The staff is very helpful in making things work for vegans, etc