If you're looking for a place that serves generous portions, fresh seafood, and a true Bronx charm, Sammy's Fish Box is it! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel right at home. The menu has something for everyone from buttery lobster tails to perfectly seasoned fried shrimp and the portions are huge (you'll definitely be taking some home). Every bite was bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere is lively, welcoming, and full of energy, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings or a fun night out. The service was fast, friendly, and attentive without being rushed. Highly recommend if you want
Karen Leemou
FOOD DISGUSTING! Their seafood is FROZEN (Calamari tasted like Burger King Onion Rings)IMITATION CRAB MEAT! Management Disregards Concern. ANYWHERE IS BETTER THAN SAMMY’s FISHBOX. Maybe that’s why they opened up a. BBQ spot across the street. HORRIBLE
ROBIN CARR
I love crab cakes I get two dinners from Sammy's and now they have cilantro in them they taste horrible. I still have them picking out cilantro. I'm not finished picking. This was a takeout order.
Charles Johnson
Took friends to eat lunch entirely.Overpriced, prices was marked up too high
Eric Francis
Food was just okay. The seasoning on the seafood was bland
Bria Pitter
Amazing!
Imani Fuller
The food wasnt fresh. Everything tasted like it had been sitting out. I got a henny colada it was warm. The service was terrible. I had to wait for the waiter for so long. Would never come back. 👎🏽
La Pantera Cabrera
Friendly waiter, Food was delicious 😋 easy parking.
Genesis Serrano
I loveeeee city island
Cherryl Allen
Sammy's seafood restaurant is still the same as far as atmosphere and comfort. Some of the waiters are still working. I remember a large order of king crab legs was under $50.00. Did i age myself. Anyway, yeah, Sammy's for still being here.
Great place for Seafood & Steaks, food and service was outstanding
Eboni Dabbs
Hubby and I been here a few times..but Sammy's Fish Box is a treasure on City Island.
The service and atmosphere is great. You cannot ask for a better, dining experience.
The seafood portions are large, definitely great value for your meal.
Jerome Green
This place is horrible. It's not the Sammy's from back in the day. I don't know what people see in this food. Opinion, don't waste your time nor your money.
Sharmila Baichu
My husband ordered.the grilled wood fire whole snapper. As he started to eat the fish he noticed a strong smell. The fish was rotten. He spit out the fish and went to the bathroom and threw up. We told the lovely waitress. She called the manager over. His name is Mickey. He did not apologize not once. He just repeated, I picked out the fish myself. We told him if he didn’t believe us to smell it. He did not smell it. His skepticism and failure to apologize was very disappointing. They did not charge us for the dish. There’s at least that. We won’t be returning to Sammy’s Fish Box. My husband felt sick the rest of the night. So unfortunate!
rob rod
I have to change my review today. Was a 5 stars, but today food was cheap, was less than half of what they used to serve. And they increase the price over 20% in the same dish I had few weeks ago. Good bye Sammys I will be trying other places, today you greed has ended a tradition in my family. If you pay $259 for a dish must be plenty full, remember you are in the Bronx not in the Hamptons.
If you're looking for a place that serves generous portions, fresh seafood, and a true Bronx charm, Sammy's Fish Box is it! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel right at home. The menu has something for everyone from buttery lobster tails to perfectly seasoned fried shrimp and the portions are huge (you'll definitely be taking some home). Every bite was bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere is lively, welcoming, and full of energy, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings or a fun night out. The service was fast, friendly, and attentive without being rushed. Highly recommend if you want
FOOD DISGUSTING! Their seafood is FROZEN (Calamari tasted like Burger King Onion Rings)IMITATION CRAB MEAT! Management Disregards Concern. ANYWHERE IS BETTER THAN SAMMY’s FISHBOX. Maybe that’s why they opened up a. BBQ spot across the street. HORRIBLE
I love crab cakes I get two dinners from Sammy's and now they have cilantro in them they taste horrible. I still have them picking out cilantro. I'm not finished picking. This was a takeout order.
Took friends to eat lunch entirely.Overpriced, prices was marked up too high
Food was just okay. The seasoning on the seafood was bland
Amazing!
The food wasnt fresh. Everything tasted like it had been sitting out. I got a henny colada it was warm. The service was terrible. I had to wait for the waiter for so long. Would never come back. 👎🏽
Friendly waiter, Food was delicious 😋 easy parking.
I loveeeee city island
Sammy's seafood restaurant is still the same as far as atmosphere and comfort. Some of the waiters are still working. I remember a large order of king crab legs was under $50.00. Did i age myself. Anyway, yeah, Sammy's for still being here.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place for Seafood & Steaks, food and service was outstanding
Hubby and I been here a few times..but Sammy's Fish Box is a treasure on City Island.
The service and atmosphere is great. You cannot ask for a better, dining experience.
The seafood portions are large, definitely great value for your meal.
This place is horrible. It's not the Sammy's from back in the day. I don't know what people see in this food. Opinion, don't waste your time nor your money.
My husband ordered.the grilled wood fire whole snapper. As he started to eat the fish he noticed a strong smell. The fish was rotten. He spit out the fish and went to the bathroom and threw up. We told the lovely waitress. She called the manager over. His name is Mickey. He did not apologize not once. He just repeated, I picked out the fish myself. We told him if he didn’t believe us to smell it. He did not smell it. His skepticism and failure to apologize was very disappointing. They did not charge us for the dish. There’s at least that. We won’t be returning to Sammy’s Fish Box. My husband felt sick the rest of the night. So unfortunate!
I have to change my review today.
Was a 5 stars, but today food was cheap, was less than half of what they used to serve.
And they increase the price over 20% in the same dish I had few weeks ago.
Good bye Sammys I will be trying other places, today you greed has ended a tradition in my family.
If you pay $259 for a dish must be plenty full, remember you are in the Bronx not in the Hamptons.
Loading...