Catskill Bagel Co.
$ • Coffee Shops, BagelsAbout Catskill Bagel Co.
Customers' Favorites
Scallion Cream Cheese with LTO
Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Bagel
Everything Bagel with Butter
Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagels
Egg and Cheese on a Roll
Breakfast Sandwich
Cortelyou Lox
Chicken Salad
Lox Bagel
Catskill Bagel Co. Reviews
204 ratings
Share your opinion about Catskill Bagel Co.
They now only put cream cheese on one half of the bagel. Got two bagels like this, totally bare on one half (there is some here because I squished to see if it would spread) I saw them put in on only half and after checking myself, asked to have cream cheese on both halves. They said it would cost extra. I understand a lot of places over do the spread, but sheesh.
Their bagels have always been smaller than others, they're fine, but they really get over being the only bagel...read full review
Their bagels have always been smaller than others, they're fine, but they really get over being the only bagel...read full review
Consistently delicious and the service is great. Been my fave for ten years.
Yummy 🥯!
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 4PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 3:30PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 4PM |
Catskill Bagel Co. is a well-loved local bagel shop known for its fresh bagels, delicious sandwiches, and hearty soups. The bagels are chewy with a crisp exterior and warm, soft interior, making them a favorite among customers. Many enjoy the scallion cream cheese and the relaxed, low-key atmosphere with plenty of seating, creating a comfortable spot to grab a bagel sandwich or some loose bagels to go. The staff is friendly and efficient, providing quick service, although some customers mention that the sandwiches can be a little under seasoned and that bacon might be undercooked.
The shop has an old-school Brooklyn vibe that many find charming, despite a $10 minimum card payment requirement that some consider inconvenient. The Reuben sandwich and the Lox bagels are standout menu items, and the soup of the day is also highly praised. The overall environment is quiet and enjoyable, with generous portion sizes and a variety of drinks available. While it can get busy during the morning rush, there is usually seating available later in the morning. The staff is accommodating of dietary restrictions, and there are plenty of vegetarian options. Catskill Bagel Co. is a place many are eager to revisit and explore more of its menu offerings, making it a great stop for a bite.