Mario's Pizza

$ • Pizza

Hours today·

About Mario's Pizza

Mario's Pizza is a Brooklyn spot known for its thin‑crust slices. Reviewers say the crust has just the right crunch, chew, and saltiness, and the sauce is balanced, not too sweet. The margherita is okay but could use more flavor. Pepperoni is less cheesy than expected. Many praise the fresh, real New York slice, saying it is the best within a 20‑minute walk and worth the price. Some note that pizza slices have gotten smaller and more expensive, and selection can run out an hour before closing. Still, the pizza is described as low‑key slaps, seasoned perfectly, with a decent char at the bottom. The place is a go‑to for a quick bite and a genuine NYC style slice.

Menu

Add a Menu
Mario's Pizza Menu
Mario's Pizza Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza
View All Photos

Mario's Pizza Reviews

4.7
71 ratings
5
74%
4
11%
3
5%
2
5%
1
5%
Food
4.5
Atmosphere
4.4
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about Mario's Pizza

Perfect slice. There’s a pizza place a few steps out my door, but i literally walk 5 blocks for this slice instead cus it’s just better and worth the walk.
Nothing fancy but good slices and nice people
Pizza slices have seemingly gotten smaller in the last year or two while getting more expensive. Often have no selection an hour or two before their advertised closing. But when you get a fresh slice and dont care about price this shop is basically the best you can get within 20 minute walk. 3.5 stars.

Read All Reviews(71)

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 2AM
Saturday 12PM - 2AM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: