Petee's Café
505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn
(646) 494-3630
Customers' Favorites
Lemon Meringue Pie and Apple Pie from Petee’S Pie
Some of the Pies Available
Wild Maine Blueberry Slice
Salty Chocolate Chess
6 Junior Apple Pie
Banana Cream Slice
Wild Blueberry Pie
Blueberry Crumb
Berry Dream Pie
Chicken Pot Pie
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I've only ever had blueberry crumb and apple crumb but I've had it many, many times. Absolutely incredible. I buy them as gifts too. Just delicious and incredible. The staff are wonderful. They're open late. Oh and I had a latte once. Their coffee is great too! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Petee's is the bar...and its extremely high. Best pie in NYC. Took a poll at my workplace near the cafe; as the neighborhood changes lunch options shift, it was unanimous, we all deeply miss Petee's savory pie options. Their chicken pot pie was like going home to visit Grandma. Outstanding. Love you guys! Thank you for all these wonderful years of perfect pie.
I’ve been going to Petee’s Pie for many years and for the first time ever I had a bad experience with the quality of the pies. Not too sure if someone new was hired for production services but I came to this location on Sunday night and ordered 4 different slices of pie, my friend ordered another 5 slices, all 9 for us to share and taste. We were both super excited because I’ve been raving about how much I love their pies. We got strawberry rhubarb, guava mascarpone, lemon...
You May Also Like
Somethin’ on Myrtle - 503 Myrtle Ave
![]()
Asian Fusion, Seafood, Caribbean
Castro's - 511 Myrtle Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
Jimmy John's - 504 Myrtle Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop