Petee's Café

505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn
(646) 494-3630

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Lemon Meringue Pie and Apple Pie from Petee’S Pie

Some of the Pies Available

Wild Maine Blueberry Slice

Salty Chocolate Chess

6 Junior Apple Pie

Banana Cream Slice

Wild Blueberry Pie

Blueberry Crumb

Berry Dream Pie

Chicken Pot Pie

Photos

+19 photos

+18 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Peteespie

Ubereats

Doordash

Trycaviar

Grubhub

Toasttab

Recent Reviews

I’ve been going to Petee’s Pie for many years and for the first time ever I had a bad experience with the quality of the pies. Not too sure if someone new was hired for production services but I came to this location on Sunday night and ordered 4 different slices of pie, my friend ordered another 5 slices, all 9 for us to share and taste. We were both super excited because I’ve been raving about how much I love their pies. We got strawberry rhubarb, guava mascarpone, lemon...

May 2025

Love their pies, perfect crust, however…

Tonight, my friends and I felt for a treat and decided to order in from Petee’s. Tell me why I opened the bag (didn’t even open the container) and 1/3 of my slice is missing 😒Why would you sell a pie slice that’s not whole?! I obviously can’t eat the rest because what if I just got someone’s half eaten pie…? This is weird man, just don’t sell the slice.

March 2025

My partner and I come here regularly for pie and for coffee/chai since we live nearby. You really can't go wrong with any option but we are partial to the the Maine Blueberry Pie. Staff is always very kind and friendly and even though there is limited seating, we can usually find a spot to sit. Love that they are open late as well.

January 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

Petee's Café

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Petee's Café