Colter Bay

561 Delaware Ave, Buffalo
(716) 436-5197

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Cheeseburger and Fries
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Firehole Falls Nachos
Vegan Beyond Burger
Short Rib Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Burger with Egg
Vegan Pretzels
Soft Pretzels

Menu

Featured items
Short Rib Melt Sandwich
Braised short rib, arugula, roasted garlic aioli, white cheddar, and red onion on griddled breadhive sourdough.
Fish & Chips
Crispy and fluffy beer battered cod, french fries, house made slaw, and tartar sauce.
Double Burger
Two four ounce burgers topped with lettuce, onion, pickles, and American cheese on a sesame bun. Served with home fries.
Mac & Cheese
Extra sharp cheddar melted into elbow noodles with crispy baked breadcrumbs on top
Buffalo Wings (10 pcs)
Served with carrots, celery, and house blue cheese.
Beef on Weck Sandwich
Classic roast beef sliced thin on a weck roll. Served with au jus and horseradish.
Wedge Salad
Panko crusted spicy buffalo chicken breast, iceberg lettuce, tomato, carrots, celery, red onion, blue crumble, and blue cheese dressing.
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Brined with spices, breaded, and then fried. Served on a toasted bun with lettuce, pickles, and mayonnaise.

Appetizers
Potato Skin
Thick sliced bacon, extra sharp cheddar, herb sour cream, and scallion on top of potato skins.
Firehole Falls Nachos
Cheese, pico de gallo, Pickled red onion, pickled jalapeno, cilantro and salsa blanco.
Mac & Cheese
Extra sharp cheddar melted into elbow noodles with crispy baked breadcrumbs on top
French Onion Soup
Crock of savory beef onion broth with croutons and melted provolone cheese.
Buffalo Wings (10 pcs)
Served with carrots, celery, and house blue cheese.
Soft Pretzels
Locally made BreadHive pretzels served with extra sharp cheddar fondue
Poutine
Hand cut fries, beef gravy and Vermont cheese curds Add beer braised short rib $5

Salads
Wedge Salad
Panko crusted spicy buffalo chicken breast, iceberg lettuce, tomato, carrots, celery, red onion, blue crumble, and blue cheese dressing.
Chopped Salmon Salad
Grilled salmon, shaved Brussels sprouts, cucumber, tomato, onion, bacon, avocado, fried egg, and creamy lemon vinaigrette.
Chicken Caesar
Greens, shaved parmesan, grilled chicken breast, topped with croutons and house made Caesar dressing,

Sandwiches
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Brined with spices, breaded, and then fried. Served on a toasted bun with lettuce, pickles, and mayonnaise.
Beef on Weck Sandwich
Classic roast beef sliced thin on a weck roll. Served with au jus and horseradish.
Short Rib Melt Sandwich
Braised short rib, arugula, roasted garlic aioli, white cheddar, and red onion on griddled breadhive sourdough.
The Frontiersman BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Slow roasted BBQ pulled chicken with cheddar cheese, bacon, and lettuce.
Rock Steady Patty Melt
Two smash pattys with caramelized onions, swiss, and special sauce on toasted marble rye. Served with fries

Burgers
Double Burger
Two four ounce burgers topped with lettuce, onion, pickles, and American cheese on a sesame bun. Served with home fries.
Split Rock Burger
House blend ground beef, braised short rib, white cheddar cheese, arugula, caramelized onion, and horseradish cracked pepper aioli.
Classic Beyond Burger
Classic vegan cheeseburger with daiya cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and onion.

Entrees
Fish & Chips
Crispy and fluffy beer battered cod, french fries, house made slaw, and tartar sauce.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+66 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+65 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This is a cornerstone of the Allentown neighborhood and we always go back. Beef on weck is the real deal that always delivers. Great location and setting and even better Buffalo staples.
September 2025
Colter Bay continues to be one of Buffalo’s gems. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between relaxed and lively—whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or meeting friends. Their beer list is outstanding, with an ever-changing rotation that always offers something new alongside trusted favorites.

The food holds its own against the stellar drink selection. Thoughtful menu choices, generous portions, and dishes that are clearly made with care—everything...
September 2025
If it was just rating the beer & service it would be 5 stars. The rating comes down just because of the food. Allso would've been nice to have the sound on for the Thursday Night Fireball game but that's not the biggest thing - I get it, some people aren't watching the game.

The burger/fries were 3 stars, regular pub food but not great. But the real problem was the Nachos weren't worth it even being half price. If I had paid full price...
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Angeline - 581 Delaware Ave
Italian, Bar, Fine Dining
La Fiesta Cantina - 73 Allen St
Mexican
Tim Hortons - 537 Delaware Ave
Coffee Shops, Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Bagels, Coffee

Colter Bay

561 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14202
(716) 436-5197