Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company
$ • Brewery, American, Irish
Hours:
73 Hamburg St, Buffalo
(716) 855-8948
About Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company
Recent Reviews
Share your opinion about Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company
Best Roast Beef sandwich!
What a joke. 4 of us walked in 408. Ordered drinks about 15 minutes later. Order our food by 425. Ten minutes later our friends messaged us saying they were gonna join. Had us order them 20 wings and fries. I then track down our elusive server. Add the food. To our order. Our friends show up. Their food comes out at 500. At 520 we still hadn’t received our food.
An hour after ordering 2 roast beef sandwiches and 10 wings and they couldn’t get it done....read full review
Gene McCarthy's - the kind of place where you can forget your wallet on the table and come back the next day to pick it up. Thank you Margo and All!!!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10:30PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10:30PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10:30PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
People in Buffalo Also Viewed
Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company is a historic tavern located in Buffalo's Old First Ward. This place offers a unique and authentic experience, with its walls and ceilings adorned with an array of memorabilia. The highlight is their in-house brewed beers, such as the popular Gene's Lager, Streaker IPA, and Razzputon raspberry ale. The menu features local favorites like the McCarthy wings, chicken fingers, Sheffield wings (dry rub), stuffed banana peppers, and the classic beef on weck. Gene's is also known for its fish fry, which is served on Wednesday and Friday with a delicious batter and generous portions. Customers praise the outstanding food and service, often describing the atmosphere as friendly and casual. While the staff is generally welcoming, some reviews mention that service can occasionally be slow. The bar area is always packed, and the outdoor patio is a great spot for dining, especially in the summertime. Street parking is available. This establishment provides a delightful blend of great beer, delicious food, and a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere, making it a top pick for visitors and locals.