facebook instagram facebook instagram

New York Pizzeria

$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings

Hours:
200 S Peterboro St, Canastota
(315) 697-3993

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

New York Pizzeria Reviews

4.1 - 133 reviews

On the busiest night of the year, Superbowl, the staff was friendly, the place was running efficiently, friendly, and clean! The food was so delicious too. Even though it was a busy night someone was managing well. The chicken winbgs were to die for. So unbelievably good, but believable as it can from the best place! Thank you for the awesome food and friendly treatment! Go Chiefs!

OK I left an EXCELLENT review YEARS Ago! DECADES AGO! That's how I knew THIS IS THE PLACE with the REALLY GREAT PIZZA! But, I guess after so many years Google deletes the review? I know I sure didn't delete the post! AWESOME PIZZA!!! And, AGAIN the gal that answered the phone was extremely nice and VERY FRIENDLY! If anyone says anything BAD about this place DON'T BELIEVE IT! THEY'RE LYING! GREAT PIZZA! GREAT PEOPLE!!!!

When we used to come up 17 on our way home, we would stop at BC Pizza and More in Deposit. Since we barely go that route and the new thruway plazas are absolutely horrible, we were looking for another place and our first experience was excellent. Staff was friendly, relaxed and even chatted my wife up about her Taylor Swift clothes.Since we probably won't be coming up 17 again, we have bookmarked this place to try again when we need to stop.They were very helpful when we were...read full review

More Reviews(133)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11AM - 8PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8PM
Thursday 11AM - 8PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday 2 - 8PM
Updated on: