Castile Cider Mill
$ • BakeryAbout Castile Cider Mill
Castile Cider Mill Reviews
105 ratings
Share your opinion about Castile Cider Mill
Darling little Cider Mill! The cider slush was great and the fry cakes were absolutely delicious! The woman that cashed us out was very friendly 😊 We have already recommended it to our family and friends!
Love coming here and have so many great memories visiting with my family. It's definitely worth the trip, no matter where you're coming from. My only complaint is that they still only accept cash or checks. It's 2026 please consider accepting cards, tap pay or venmo. It would make the experience much more convenient. Nobody carries cash anymore. Everyone i know always has to make a separate trip to withdraw money out to be able to go down. Other than that, it's a great place and...read full review
I went to Letchworth State Park and stopped by to buy, apples, donuts and apple cider. The store is only open 2 months annually. The cider is simply delicious. I also bought maple syrup and honey.
I highly recommend visiting this store if you are in the area. They only accept cash or check they don’t accept any cards.
I highly recommend visiting this store if you are in the area. They only accept cash or check they don’t accept any cards.
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 5PM |
Castile Cider Mill is a charming shop known for its delicious cider fry cakes and a variety of local goods. The cider is fresh, sweet, and truly delightful, especially the cider slushies. Visitors can watch apples being ground or pressed on beautiful fall days, adding a special touch to the experience. The shop also offers the Sweet Mary and big warm pretzels with cheesy sauce. Cash or check only, so customers should be prepared. The apple cider fry cakes are highly praised, described as phenomenal and worth trying even if someone usually doesn't like donuts. The shop is considered the best place for apple cider donuts, with many visitors missing it once it closes by November. Though some find it a bit pricey, they agree it is always worth it because the treats are always fresh, warm, and delicious. It is a favorite stop before heading to Letchworth State Park for an annual fall tradition.