9 Best Caribbean Restaurants near Central Islip

Nyam Sum Jamaican Cuisine Jamaican • $
70 W Suffolk Ave, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Rasta Pasta with Jerk Chicken
Rice and Cabbage Only Meal
Brown Stew Chicken Large
Fried Chicken Dinner
Jamaican Beef Patty
Jamaican Coco Bread
Jerk Chicken Small
Paella Valenciana
Jerk Chicken Meal
Rice \u0026 Peas

“We recently visited the area for six days and ate here four of those six days 😂(would’ve been all six had we found it earlier!) Amazing food, great people, and loved their fresh hibiscus tea! Cannot beat the $7.99 lunch price either! 🤩 Highly recommend!“

4.3 Superb199 Reviews
Mo's Island Spice Authentic Jamaican Cuisine Jamaican • $
18 Woods Corner Rd, Setauket- East Setauket - 10.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

1 Doz Jamaican Jerk Chicken Wings
Oxtail \u0026 Beans 1 2 Tray
Sweet Plantain Tart
Jamaican Rum Cake
Chicken Patties
Vegetable Patty
Mac and Cheese
Rice and Beans
Stew Chicken
Kids Tshirts

“The Jerk Chicken was so tasty!!! Can’t wait to try more dishes.“

4.9 Superb87 Reviews
Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge Cuban • $$$
944 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown - 4.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pork Shank with Arroz Con Gandules
Little Havana House Salad
Tapas Cuban Sandwich
Cuban Surf and Turf
Homemade Lava Cake
Skirt Steak Mofongo
Tres Leches Cake
Coconut Mussels
Petite Churrasco
Coconut Shrimp

“Omg Amazing food, great drinks and perfect ending with the flan 🍮 😍 to die for, highly recommend!!!!“

4.5 Superb138 Reviews
Caribeno Restaurant Incorporated Caribbean • $
278 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 4.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Full Chicharrones de Pollo Sin Hueso
Half Chicharrones de Pollo Con Hueso
Full Chicharrones de Pollo Con Hueso
Beef or Chicken Empanadas Per Dozen
Full Arroz Moro O Con Vegetales
Chicharrón de Pollo Sin Hueso
Baked Chicken Pollo Al Horno
Pork Feet Patitas de Puerco
Beef Stew Carne Guisada
Mofongo de Camarones

“Small space. I love some of their options...
There has been times food wasn't the best.
But there has been more good day then bad. I do go there often cause it's close to home and they have a great selection . Tasty Dominican cuisine“

3.8 Good47 Reviews
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar Cocktail Bar • $$
12 E Main St, Bay Shore - 5.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Korean BBQ Steak Sandwich
Jerk Chicken Quesadilla
Surf and Turf Burger
Jerk Chicken Tacos
The Cubano Sandwich
Jerk Chicken Bowl
The Lobster Roll
Coastal Burger
Fish Tacos
Poke Bowl

“Stumbled across this AMAZING spot with friends! Service, drinks, food, and vibe were all on point! Thank you! I will be back!“

4.1 Good91 Reviews
Willie's Delight Jamaican • $
831 Long Island Ave, Deer Park - 6.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jerk Chicken with Steamed Vegetables and Plantain
Large Curry Chicken with Rice and Plantains
Pineapple Jerk Salmon
Sweet Fried Plantains
Brown Stew Chicken
Ackee and Saltfish
Saltfish Fritters
Ackee & Saltfish
Cook Up Saltfish
Fried Dumplings

“Well I have been waiting for a good Jamaican spot for a longggg time I been here 2 in 48hours. I went late last night. We got a jerk chicken and the pea soup. The pea soup was prob the best I have ever had. Has no meat in it but the dude that worked there said trust me u will come back for it and we did. It wasn’t finished wen we can back the next morn but we got stew chicken and it was good . The festival that they had was like a little knot and it was awesome! Unlike every other Jamaican spot they greeted us. They were not nasty and rude. They didn’t make me feel bad for giving them my money. So glad that they opened deff a 5star place. I will drive past every spot that I live by to go further down the road to come here !!“

3.9 Good115 Reviews
La Cabaña Restaurant & Lounge Dominican • $$
1026 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood - 1.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Arrow Abichuela Con Carnita Frita
La Cabana Mofongo Seafood Mix
Churrasco La Cabana Special
Pasta Alfredo Con Pollo
Lemon Chicken
Passion Fruit
Mar & Tierra
Tripe Soup
Tostones

“It was great and the food was awesome!“

3.4 Good67 Reviews
Big Taste Jamaican • $
1048 Islip Ave Unit B, Brentwood - 1.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Beef Patty
Stewed Chicken
Jerk Chicken

“I knew this place was the real deal as soon as I saw the beef patty flake in my hands. It was delicious and so was my jerk chicken, peas and rice and cabbage. The chicken had the perfect spice - enough to clear my sinuses but not slow me down.

My only wish is that I had ordered more!“

3 Average36 Reviews
Island Jerk Jamaican • $
1350 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon - 7.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brown Stew Chicken with Roti
Sweet & Spicy Chicken Meal
Fried Chicken Meal
Curry Shrimp Meal
Goat Head Soup
Stew Pork Meal
Cow Foot Soup
Chicken Soup
Curried Goat
Caesar Salad

“I've been eating here for years, one of the best Jamaican food you can find around that area. With that been said, the food is not the issue but there is this particular female that doesn't gives a rats ass about the business. I never got her name, but her attitude stinks. She doesn't greet customers and speak to everyone just the same, she wears some long eyelashes and move slower than snail even when there's a long line. She's always on her phone, nevermind the long line of customers waiting to place their order. I went in there one morning before work and I just wanted to get 2 patties but she was there talking on her phone and moving even more slower that morning and about 4 people was ahead of me in the line. She's been there for a while, so I'm guessing she might own the business or related to whoever runs it. I'm not one to do reviews, but her attitude will surely push away good customers.“

3 Average80 Reviews