10 Best Caribbean Restaurants in Baldwin

1 POPS AND POOSH CARIBBEAN KITCHEN

4.6 Superb 141 Reviews

988 Merrick Rd, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My Family and I just finished having a late lunch here. The food was sooooo good and the service was great, we appreciate the staff accommodating our large party in such a short notice. The vibe was super chill and Pops was dope, came thru with a few samples 🙏🏾 Thanks again, we will be back next time we are in NYC.”

2 Tinnels Patties

4.7 Superb 69 Reviews

682 Sunrise Highway, Baldwin

“TinNel’s Patties in Baldwin is an absolute must! Their patties are consistently fresh, flavorful, and perfectly spiced. The girls working there are always sweet and friendly. A must-try for anyone craving authentic and delicious Jamaican patties. Highly recommend!”

3 COALHOUSE EXPRESS AND MARKET

4.6 Superb 9 Reviews

2380 Grand Avenue, Baldwin

• Delivery

“Coalhouse Express and Market is hands down one of the best spots for authentic Jamaican food in the area. The flavors are bold, rich, and consistent every time you visit. From the perfectly seasoned jerk chicken to the tender oxtail and fresh sides, everything tastes like it’s made with real care and passion. The staff is welcoming, the service is quick, and the overall vibe makes you feel like you’re getting a true Caribbean experience right here in Baldwin. You can tell they take pride in both their food and their customers. If you’re looking for high-quality Jamaican cuisine with great portions and unforgettable flavor, this is definitely a place you need to try. Highly recommend!”

4 Jerk Kingz

4.0 Good 147 Reviews

1016 Atlantic Avenue, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My fiance got us dinner today & I must say it taste very great. We have been looking for a good Jamaican restaurant for some time now. Every cook has slight dif flavor and you can always taste the dif in food. The food was healthy & the overall service provided was very respectful. We also felt full and great after our meal! Looking forward to coming again :)”

5 Appleton Estate Restaurant & Lounge

4.2 Good 45 Reviews

1299 Grand Avenue, Baldwin

• Delivery

“I did not try the food but will soon. The service was very inviting. The bartenders were great. I enjoyed the music provided by Dj Lennox. 4 Stars right now because I did not order food. I went for the music and a drink. I'm sure the amount of stars will go up after I try some food.”

6 Tony Mac Bakery&Restaurant Baldwin

3.5 Good 19 Reviews

1293 Grand Avenue, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I got delivery through GrubHub and it was really good. I chose mild for my wife's sake, but the flavor still was NOT lacking. The curry goat was deliciously strong in both curry and goat. The roti was one of the best I've had. The oxtail was exactly what I hoped for. Even the rice and peas impressed me. This was the best Caribbean meal I've had in a long time”

7 West Island Grill

3.7 Good 56 Reviews

1173 Grand Avenue, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Came in today for a jerk salad and a side of Mac and cheese . The server innocently rang it up as pasta but they corrected the error with no problem and were very nice about it . Let me say , the jerk salad was DELICIOUS. Definitely worth the money , the chicken was a little spicy , super flavorful and juicy . The mango’s and cucumbers in the salad were fresh. The side of Mac and cheese was the best I have had at any Caribbean restaurant in the entire area and I’ve lived here for over 20 years. Definitely a great experience and I will be coming back for more !!!”

8 Breezes Island Grill Restaurant & Lounge

3.8 Good 226 Reviews

1971 Grand Avenue, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food, drinks and customer service.”

9 Royal Roti Shop

3.3 Good 188 Reviews

1747 Grand Avenue, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best tasting Caribbean Food !!!! ?”

10 Tropical Jerk Baldwin

3.1 Average 132 Reviews

1321 Grand Ave, Baldwin

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“sweet sauce with jerk chicken good rice n beans good as well”