Restaurants near Cincinnatus

Tinellis 3976 NY-41, Cincinnatus American • $$
3976 NY-41, Cincinnatus

“Very nice wedding venue. Food was hot and delicious, but service was very slow both at the bar and for the sit-down dinner, and seemed either somewhat disorganized or maybe just understaffed. Grounds were pretty and great for outdoor pics.”

4.8 Superb9 Reviews
Magros Italia Pizzeria 5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus Pizza • $
5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus

Customers` Favorites

Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Garlic Knots w Sauce
Mozzarella Sticks
Antipasto
5 Wings

“Ordered two sheet pizzas for an event this evening. They were ready for me when I came to pick them up. The guy on the shift was very friendly and accommodating, offering to carry the pizzas out to my vehicle for me. The pizzas were good, no short-cuts with the sauce or cheese. The pieces were cut through, which was a big help when we were serving the pizza at our event. A few times a year my organization orders sheet pizzas from Magros, as we really don't have anything else in our town. The quality has, over the years, varied somewhat; but, we like supporting our local businesses. This time Magros was "spot on."”

4.1 Good19 Reviews
Reilly's Cafe 8 E Main St, Marathon American • $
8 E Main St, Marathon - 9.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Gravy over Biscuits
4 Slices of French Toast
Eggs Toast & Home Fries
Western Egg Sandwich
Buttermilk Pancakes
Breakfast Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito
Western Omelette
Farmers Omelette
Corned Beef Hash

“Stopped by on a whim for a late lunch. Very impressed with the food. Had the special which was Guinness battered fish sandwich with coleslaw. All of it was really good including the perfectly crisp fries.”

5 Superb29 Reviews
Brackel Pub and Grub 107 Kinny Rd, McDonough Bar & Grill • $
107 Kinny Rd, McDonough - 4.94 miles

“Great food. Friendly service. Like being at home without having to do the dishes.Wheelchair accessibility: No dedicated Handicap space, but a huge, flat parking lot. I had no problem finding a safe and accessible place to park the lift van. The door is street level, and it is easy to enter the building with a wheelchair”

4.9 Superb9 Reviews
The Brackel Grub and Pub 107 Kinny Rd, McDonough Bar & Grill • $
107 Kinny Rd, McDonough - 4.94 miles

“Enjoyed my visit. Affordable bar food and drinks. Dinning available inside, outside, and a Pavilion.Location is secluded but worth the drive.Staff was friendly and attentive.”

5 Superb5 Reviews
6

Mijos

Mijos 9 W Main St, Marathon Bar & Grill • $
9 W Main St, Marathon - 10.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fajita

“Small town bar with great food. Hands down probably the best bang for your buck in cortland County. If you haven't been you should check it out. Grab a burger they don't disappoint.”

4.7 Superb23 Reviews
Murray's Pizza 1576 State Rte 26, South Otselic Pizza • $
1576 State Rte 26, South Otselic - 9.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wings
Garlic Knots
Meatballs
White Pie
Roasted Peppers
Calabrian Chili
Fresh Garlic
Plain Cheese
Tomato Pie

“Murray’s is the best! The food is incredible! From his tasty recipes, with an original flair to the classic rock theme! I would recommend anything on the menu, but our go to is his special soups and enormous calzones. My husband also loves his wings, with the multiple sauces to choose from. I would highly recommend anyone to take the trip to South Otselic for this delicious food! It is definitely worth the trip! It is more than just a pizza place it is an experience!”

4.4 Superb31 Reviews
Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria Marathon 1 E Main St, Marathon Italian • $
1 E Main St, Marathon - 9.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Teriyaki Chicken and Onion Pizza
Seafood Alfredo with Fettuccine
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Chicken Wing Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread

“Food is wonderful. Very clear and love the staff.Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly...Wheelchair accessibility: It's walk in and chairs can be moved.”

3.6 Good24 Reviews