Athenian Greek Taverna


2188 Jericho Turnpike, Commack
(631) 499-7660


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Athenian Greek Taverna

Ordered on 05/09/20 - We were looking forward to going here but unfortunately not the best experience. The young woman who helped us was not friendly. We ordered a Greek salad with chicken and the King George gyro, which came with a side of avgolemono soup. The soup was good, not amazing. The salad was very big but not flavorful. The gyro was bland, the pork was tough, and it was filled with mostly shredded lettuce. For an $18 salad and a $15 gyro, I expected more.

Ok my fav Greek is Mykonos... always happy. Today they are closed it's about he Covid-19. So I thought I'd try the new place in Commack Athenian Tavern. Not happy....they didn't carry a eggplant pita??? Really and my son has always ordered the Greek meatballs. Ok those meatballs were simply a hamburger broken into pieces. So again this is a new place I'm trying. So I ordered the falafels and dry hard and tasteless. Ok so this place oh and I called to complain bc a full review

The grilled Octopus is always a must order. It’s always so tender. But if you get the Saganaki as well, try layering some of the melty cheese with a piece of octopus on a soft pita. You will not be disappointed. The crabmeat stuffed Salmon Fillet was deliciously cloaked with their creamy avgolemono sauce. Just thinking about it is making me hungry for more!

More Reviews(149)


Monday 11AM - 9:30PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9:30PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9:30PM
Thursday 11AM - 9:30PM
Friday 11AM - 9:30PM
Saturday 11AM - 9:30PM
Sunday 12 - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.