12 Best American Restaurants near Copake Falls

“We hadn’t been here in many years. Glad we stopped in. Will be back..“

“It’s truly the best of the best“

“Wednesday night, the place was packed and deservedly so…. It was amazing. Despite being crowded, our host Terry seated us within 3 minutes. The food was amazing, the service was on point and the lounge vibe makes me want to come back soon. Thanks for a great night Old Mill.“

“The food was spectacular and the service was outstanding. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Eat there all the time good price and good food“

“Jackson was our server and he did an Awesome job! The food was Amazing! He brought us a delicious Anniversary cake for our 1st wedding anniversary! 😊😊“

“Was great food and fun all day“

“Great accommodations, comfortable and well located in the hamlet of Hillsdale. I would definitely stay there again. There were some stairs to our rooms though, so that might be a little tough if you have mobility problems, though they also seemed to have nice ground level cabins.“

“Truly loved it! Beautiful restaurant with a cute rustic cozy feel and great atmosphere. As someone who eats out a lot, I wasn't sure what to expect but the food was excellent. From the Signature, Caprese Salad, the delicious brick oven pizza, the Rack of Lamb for my husband all through to dessert, everything was extremely flavorful and delicious. The hot food came out hot, a pet peeve of mine is when it comes out luke warm from sitting to be served. Here everything was perfectly temperature. And can we talk about the cocktails? LOVED the Neo’s Negroni. 5 stars from me fully recommend this amazing restaurant won’t be disappointed!“

“Friday AM Garden Omelet, coffee GREAT! Thanks!“

“Visited at the tail end of July 4th weekend. It was apparent that staff was running on fumes but everyone was still very kind. I sampled the kolsch, rye lager, ESB, and a newly tapped hazy pale ale. The kolsch and pale were particularly good. Got the bratwurst with onions and cheese. Pro tip: the brat already comes with mustard, just top it with that. Use the cheese on the fries. They make them in house and you can tell. I would like to come back in the winter on a random day and try what dark beers they have then.“

“We held our reunion there yesterday for the Roe Jan class of 1968. The Clock Tower is an excellent place for a reunion; we started out in the (spacious) bar section, then moved to their dining room, which we had reserved in advance for just us. The staff could not have been more accommodating and friendly, the waitress was wonderful, and the food was delicious. Thank you for a great experience!“