6 Best Bakeries in Cortland

Hollenbeck's Cider Mill Bakery • $$
1265 NY-392, Cortland

“Fun to watch the cider press!“

4.7 Superb45 Reviews
East Side Bakery Bakery • $
122 Elm St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Twists
Cinnamon Roll
Cannolis

“East side bakery is absolutely AMAZING! We just moved to the Cortland area and my daughter was celebrating her first birthday. Christine, went above and beyond in my daughter’s cake! The cake was absolutely delicious and everything we had hoped for and more! Christine puts her heart and soul into baking and the design work and it truly shows. We also got a sheet cake that was of course —-delicious! Thank you East Side Bakery for making my daughter’s first birthday one of the best memories for us! We are definitely returning customers and are blessed to have found your bakery! Photo credit to Mackenzie Jo Photography“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
New York Bagel Bakery • $
33 Main St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Burrito
blt Bagel Sandwich
Bacon Scallion
Sesame Bagels
Acai Bowl

“I consistently find a wonderful clean environment with great food gracious employees & a welcoming atmosphere. They have a creative menu of sandwiches & freshly made bagels. It's become a community hub & the owner works alongside his employees; & mingles with his customers thanking them for their patronage! I give it a total A+++“

4.5 Superb41 Reviews
Frosted Bakery • $
133 Main St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Variety Cookies

“Our daughter said the cupcakes were the best she ever tasted! Thank you, Frosted, for the excellent customer service and delicious treats!“

4.6 Superb23 Reviews
A Lovin Cup Coffee Shops • $
234 Tompkins St, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Vegan Cinnamon Roll
Avocado Toast
Bruschetta

“Very Cool place close to SUNY Cortland Campus. Excellent drinks and cafe food!! Vegan items specifically identified. Both Almond and Oat Milk available for drinks. We got the Ciabatta breakfast sandwich.. which was Out of This World!! Double layer of ‘egg’ with perfectly spiced sausage and super melty vegan cheese. Baked goods were also exceptional. Vegan Cinnamon Roll with cream cheese topping was deemed by my wife as… “The Best EVER!!” Beautiful hand crafted custom hard wood bar.. as well as Vintage Concert posters that will take you on a trip back in time. Very limited vegan options in the Cortland area.. plug the address not your Apple Maps and make this place your Destination Stop. #Veganuary“

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Perkins American Food Co. Bakery • $
2 Locust Ave, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

French Toast and Bacon with Scrambled Eggs
Strawberry Crepes with Sausage Links
Scratch-Made Belgian Waffle Platter
Strawberries and Creme Crepes
Cinnamon French Toast Platter
Hash Brown and Avocado Toast
Waffle and Eggs Any Style
Pumpkin Pancakes Platter
Classic Eggs Benedict
The Breakfast Burger

“The new French toast platter was absolutely amazing, we enjoyed the banana walnut and the chocolate covered strawberry French toast. The only disappointment I had was there was too much chocolate not enough strawberry. Otherwise very delicious, sorry no pictures as I was too into the food to stop to snap a picture“

3.8 Good88 Reviews

Cortland’s Other Flavors