5 Best Ice Cream Shops near Cortland

“cute little diner with good food and ice cream. the workers are very nice and friendly“

“Classic American mom and pop ice cream stand. There was a line of 10 or so people when I arrived, so patience is key.
I got a Texas hot with lemonade and some chips and a Lemon Cheesecake Bar ice cream, it was quite good.

Bring Cash. 👍“

“I love this restaurant so clean and well maintained. The servers are always nice and on top of everything. Management is the best“

“Affordable, delicious, & they have “pup cups” for doggie friends. 💗💗“

“My boyfriend has an affinity for ice cream cake, so I get one every year for his birthday. I personally cannot stand them. Generic, tastes like plastic, and is usually some obscene color that stains your teeth. So this year I decided to try something a little different, and have it custom made - at Super Cream Dairy Bar.

Best. Decision. Ever.

We had previously gotten their ice cream advent calendars -cannot recommend these enough - that were suggested to us by a friend who lives there locally (we are about an hour away). We became obsessed with a specific seasonal flavor (the caramel corn), and luckily for me they had enough of this flavor left to do an entire ice cream cake. I reached out on Facebook, and Sheena was SO helpful and kind in getting my order together for me. She gave great suggestions, and we ended up with the best ice cream cake either of us has ever had. And it was even cuter than I had expected it to be! Thank god it’s just the two of us, and we don’t have to share with anyone else.

Great product, and exceptional customer service. This was the very delicious start, to a wonderful new birthday tradition.“