Ice Cream Shops near Ithaca

Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall Ice Cream Shop • $
215 N Cayuga St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Cookies

“The ice cream is pretty good here! Got the Trick or Treat (vanilla and marshmallow base with candy inside). As someone who appreciates contrasting textures, I loved the soft, icy sweetness of the vanilla ice cream with the crunch of the MnM and sprinkles. Delicious! It's a little pricey, but a one-scoop is more than enough with a waffle cone for about $8. They don't really skimp on the ice cream, and offer samples. They're all-in for Halloween, with lots of decorations around the store, a pumpkin decorating crafting station, Halloween candy bags, and 30% for coming in with a costume. Would definitely recommend!“

4.7 Superb45 Reviews
Cornell Dairy Bar Ice Cream Shop • $
411 Tower Rd Stocking Hall, Ithaca

“Wonderful experiences here over many years. My son is a Cornell undergraduate in Ithaca, NY, so we visit often. The ice cream is home-made by Cornell students from local dairy cows. The Cornell Dairy Bar is in a cafeteria located on campus in a modern building with big glass windows. The space is well-lit with lots of small tables and chairs. The dairy bar serves many unique flavors of home-made ice cream, cones, ice cream floats, sandwiches with vegan options, burgers and hot dogs (of meat or vegan options), a wide variety of drinks, coffees, teas and bottled waters. No beer or alcoholic beverages are available. Prices are very modest and reasonable. Food, service and the local ambiance are excellent, and everything is managed by Cornell students. Ice cream is fresh and flavorful, very smooth and creamy, so it melts easily in your mouth. If you're dieting or vegan, this is definitely worth suspending diet or vegan habits because the interesting, innovative flavors are unpredictable but remarkable and surprising, especially delightful because everything is created and managed by Cornell students, teachers and staff.“

4.6 Superb70 Reviews
Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
200 W Seneca St, Ithaca

“CASH ONLY but amazing ice cream. Rotating homemade soft serve flavors and hard ice cream too. Don't bother with Purity--this is the true pinnacle of Ithaca ice cream. Also, you can stand across the street from a strange church and read the inscriptions.“

4.4 Superb34 Reviews
Insomnia Cookies Ice Cream • $
319 College Ave, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Cream Cheese Icing
Brownie
Cookies

“I’m always curious to stop by here coz it’s cute store color decoration. I tried it first on an event but it was so so coz it’s cold. This time i got it warm, freshly baked, so it tastes good. Recommended!Dietary restrictions: Vegan gluten“

3 Average21 Reviews
Purity Ice Cream Co. Ice Cream Shop • $
700 Cascadilla St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough After Dark
Chocolate Ice Cream
Chocolate Chip
Ice Cream Cone
Brownie Sundae
Banana Split
Waffle Cone
Mocha Chip
Strawberry
Mint Chip

“First time here! No doubt their ice cream is fabulous and better than any i have had at a shop or in store. They were also very busy but managed. I got the chocolate peanut butter, there wasn’t really that much peanut butter in it but the ice cream itself was a great flavor. I also got the chocolate chip cookie dough which was better than choc PB, rich, smooth flavor and the cookie dough itself was just different in the best way possible, only downside was there was about 3 cookie dough pieces. Overall, choc PB was a 8.2 and the choc cookie dough was a 9.3 in my book. One bite everyone knows the rules.“

3.7 Good128 Reviews
Dotties Ice Cream Bakery • $$
788 Buck Rd, Groton

“Dottie is not only a wonderful cake baker, but she is also so caring and kind-hearted. Throughout our wedding planning process, she listened to all of our needs and remained flexible when we went through an event date change. There's nothing worse than a dry wedding cake, and let me say that Dottie's was far from it. Everyone enjoyed our cake and kept raving about it! It may have been a little too good, since we didn't get our leftovers back from the venue... Being the kind-spirit that she is, dottie offered to take time out of her busy schedule to make us another cake. You definitely won't go wrong with hiring her for your event! Oh, and remember to keep an eye out for your leftovers at your venue.“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Loading...

Ithaca’s related cuisines

map Map