6 Best Ice Cream Shops near Watkins Glen

“I will give this Ben and Jerry's a four star review only and only because of the young blond that was working her little tail feathers off while four other young men..her coworkers were fratanizing. I would like to see personalized tips in this establishment. Thank you! Michelle McMillen“

“New owners recently (local!), same great ice cream (Hershey's and their own). Highly recommend.“

“A favorite spot for my brother and I. We drove by after 9 tonight and the owner turned the lights back on and made sure we got our ice cream fix. 10/10 recommend. Good ice cream and even better people. And a fraction of the cost compared to other places.“

“No one influenced me to leave this review. My best friend told me she ate here and how amazing it was. The chef has wine flour, yes, wine flour that can be dusted on the dough before adding toppings, that was glorious. So we drove 2 hours to come here. I believed her, but now I get it. I just had the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life! Give the master chef, Mario, a raise! I can’t believe how outstanding the flavors and texture, crispiness, and freshness just exploded in my mouth! If you have the good fortune to be in Watkins Glen, you must eat here. There’s an ice creamery here too with a long and respectable line. Don’t skip out on the most amazing pizza in the United States.“

“Mario, legend. 10/10. First time meeting him, I’d join his cult if he had one. Super friendly guy, played great tunes, knew his way around a pizza.
Pizza- 10/10. My friend and I played F marry kill with food, I married this pizza. Mario generously offered to let us try a special wine flour in our pie dough, basically a spiritual experience, will be chasing that high for the rest of my life.
Price 10/10- cheaper than eating at Taco Bell, which is still blowing my mind.
Atmosphere 9/10- road side people watching was top notch. Point docked for it being too far away from where I live. Will update to 10/10 when I move into the parking lot next door.“

“Love ❤️ Have never been a fan of ice cream but this soft serve 🍦 is the best ! Great customer service“