Ice Cream Shops in Penn Yan

Mac's Dairy Bar Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
2605 NY-14A, Penn Yan

“Fabulously rich Hershey’s ice cream. All the standard flavors plus wild concoctions like Banana Peanut Butter Moose tracks which is as yellow as you would hope it to be. Of course they have soft serve, sundaes and all the toppings and dips.“

4.8 Superb32 Reviews
The Corner Coop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt •
2475 NY-54A, Penn Yan

“We originally wanted to go to Seneca Farms, the restaurant across the street, but they closed for the season. They are associated with The Corner Coop, which houses some Seneca Farms ice creams. However, the Corner Coop has a wide variety of gifts, as well as some other snacks and drinks. They have a lot of Finger Lakes themed gifts, Keuka Lake items, and some Seneca Farms merchandise. We talked to the woman behind the counter for a bit, and she was very nice and helpful in telling us a bit about the store, Seneca Farms, and what the next stop should be in our day trip. I bought a nice blue finger lake shirt and a Finger Lakes magnet.“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Spotted Duck Ice Cream Shop • $
999 NY-54, Penn Yan

Customers` Favorites

Flight of Four Different Custards
Duck Egg Ice Cream
Ice Cream Flight
Frozen Custard
Java Junction
Duck

“Incredibly unique experience, with a wide array of flavors to try. Enjoy the farm experience from one of many picnic tables. Occasionally they also have food trucks to offer full meal to go with this one-of-a-kind treat. Worth the scenic drive for sure.“

4.6 Superb122 Reviews
Seneca Farms Ice Cream Shop • $
2485 NY-54A, Penn Yan

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken
Corn Fritters
French Fries

“We vacationed at the Finger Lakes in mid-October & were lucky enough to hit this place a few days before it closed for the season. We had read great reviews for the fried chicken so we made a special trip there. The chicken & corn fritters were really good. After the meal we also indulged in the highly rated ice cream. Delicious! The atmosphere would have been better in warmer weather, because there are beautiful places to eat outside. And of course, who doesn't live a gift shop!“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
Loading...

Taste More Cuisines In Penn Yan

map Map