Colonial Inn & Creamery
$ • Ice Cream, Pet FriendlyAbout Colonial Inn & Creamery
Colonial Inn & Creamery Reviews
Great pizza with shaded seating! Very fast service, interesting selection of novelty soda and just a 5 min walk from the glen trail head.
I chose this place as I had been here several times to get ice cream after hiking the Gorge, which is only .2 of a mile away. Check in was easy- Shawna?? who worked behind the ice cream counter did double duty, she checked us in and sold us our ice cream- which was great! She was very very pleasant! There are two pianos in the parlor you can sit at and play! We stayed in room #15. The room was clean and simple, however the airconditioner was hard to figure out because...read full review
Loved the ice cream!
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
The Colonial Inn & Creamery offers a charming and welcoming atmosphere, featuring clean and well-maintained facilities. The ice cream is a major draw, known for its delicious homemade flavors and large portions, making it a popular choice among locals and visitors alike. Many customers recommend skipping national brands like Ben & Jerry's for this unique ice cream experience. Conveniently located in Watkins Glen, the inn is within walking distance of downtown restaurants and shops, as well as the Seneca Wine Trail and the Gorge. Nearby, visitors can enjoy pizza at Mike's during the summer, adding to the appeal of this ideal destination for a memorable experience. The friendly staff enhances the overall visit, making it a great spot for families looking to enjoy a late snack outside in the rocking chairs. Guests can also play the two pianos in the parlor, and staying at the inn offers a 25% discount on ice cream.
Recent visitors describe it as the perfect quick lunch stop after visiting Watkins Glen, where they enjoyed the wood-fired pizza and sparkling lemonade, especially on warm days. The location is fabulous, right by the state park and Main Street, with outdoor seating and the cutest rocking chairs on the front porch. The wood fire pizza is outstanding and a must-try, while the creamery offers sweet treats that satisfy the palate. Many locals visit frequently, especially in spring and summer, for pizza made to order in the wood-fired oven and friendly service. Some guests note that the room air conditioner can be hard to figure out, and that a towel may be needed under the door to block hallway light. The milkshakes are excellent, made with their own ice cream, and the inn offers off-street parking, which is a big plus in Watkins Glen. Overall, the Colonial Inn & Creamery remains a beloved spot for both great food and a warm, inviting atmosphere.