4 Best Ice Cream Shops near Elmira

1 Grand Central Creamery

4.7 Superb 198 Reviews

1687 Grand Central Avenue, Elmira

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“I was looking forward to hard ice cream but none of the flavors sounded good. I like peanut butter and they had lots with peanut butter and they had lots of other good flavors just nothing i wanted. I was very happy with my sundae tho. My partner got an orange vanilla swirl cone. He did not like it.”

2 The Lilly Pad

4.9 Superb 38 Reviews

627 Pennsylvania Avenue, Elmira

“What a cute place! The lady who waited on me was so sweet, and gave me great recommendations :) The Oatmazing Berry Acai is delicious!”

3 Maple Lawn Dairy

4.4 Superb 254 Reviews

3162 Lower Maple Avenue, Elmira

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The first restaurant I ever ate at that I left hungry. My friends and I go on my days off. I had not eaten all day. It is the only place that I can get liver and onions. The cook always does an amazing job. Just right, not tough. I'll recommend you every time for quality. I politely asked my server if I could order extra meat. I said I would GLADLY pay more if I could be accommodated. I was flatly told that she didn't see how that was possible, she couldn't see how she could bill for it. I was offered an extra salad if I was that hungry. My request was not forwarded to her supervisor or owner. This was on a Friday night and the place smelled amazing! I was there for the meat and my stomach was rumbling. I wasn't even offered the option to purchase two meals! I payed my bill, four adults and deserts. It was over $121.00. I left angry with myself that I barely tipped 10%. I am a generous tipper. Usually over 20%. Really! You let me leave there still hungry?”

4 Kool Treats Ice Cream

3.5 Good 13 Reviews

27B Log Haven Acres Drive, Elmira

• Take-Out
• Delivery