13 Best Ice Cream Shops near Horseheads

The Dairy Barn Ice Cream Shop • $
107 Hibbard Rd, Horseheads

Customers` Favorites

Sundae

“best Texas hots in the area!“

4.7 Superb129 Reviews
Bella's Ice Cream Parlor Ice Cream Shop •
3191 S Main St, Horseheads

“Service was great, location was SPOTLESS, and beautifully decorated. The outside is very nice and would be great to have an outdoor event (unsure if they offer private events, but they definitely should!) We didn’t order anything too fancy, and I can’t say anything for the food. We had a great chat in the a/c on a really hot evening. Would definitely return.“

4.6 Superb64 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
2614 Corning Rd, Horseheads

Customers` Favorites

Ice with Creme
Orange Gelato

“If my girlfriend is mad at me, this is the go-to place! I don't mind it myself the desserts speak for themselves and are delicious! Decent prices, I suppose, but what really is these days? They also offer outside tables for your enjoyment.“

4.5 Superb136 Reviews
The Last Stand Ice Cream Shop • $
129 Ridge Rd, Horseheads

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Praline Turtle
Chocolate Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Cups
Strawberry Sundae
Ice Cream Cone
Hot Fudge

“best place on planet earth for coffee, ice cream and breakfast. all of the staff are wonderful, considerate and great at what they do. we love the last stand.“

4.4 Superb194 Reviews
sweetFrog Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
1625 County Rd 64, Horseheads

Customers` Favorites

Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet

“Service is always friendly! I feel bad for these girls having to deal with teens that pose as customers and have no adult supervision, they play pranks on the two girls behind the counter by deliberately dropping their ice cream and toppings on the floor after the girls swept and clean because it was close to closing time. These rowdy boys where taking videos of their pranks and laughing all the way. Poor girls had to clean up again.

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly but if they have they have no manner please supervise them.“

3.6 Good112 Reviews
Grand Central Creamery American • $
1687 Grand Central Ave, Elmira - 2.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Queen of Hearts Chocolate Panda Paws on a Waffle Cone
Small Twist with Chocolate Sprinkles
Upside Down Banana Split
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Ice Cream
Banana Cream Pie
Toasted Coconut
Bottled Water
Sundaes

“I was looking forward to hard ice cream but none of the flavors sounded good. I like peanut butter and they had lots with peanut butter and they had lots of other good flavors just nothing i wanted. I was very happy with my sundae tho. My partner got an orange vanilla swirl cone. He did not like it.“

4.7 Superb123 Reviews
The Royal Treat Ice Cream Shop • $
4371 Main St, Millport - 7.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Sundae
Hot Fudge Sundae

“Love ❤️ Have never been a fan of ice cream but this soft serve 🍦 is the best ! Great customer service“

4.8 Superb53 Reviews
The Lilly Pad Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt •
627 Pennsylvania Ave, Elmira - 6.57 miles

“What a cute place! The lady who waited on me was so sweet, and gave me great recommendations :) The Oatmazing Berry Acai is delicious!“

5 Superb28 Reviews
McClary's Ice Cream Stand American • $$
6017-6019 NY-13 Scenic, Cayuta - 10.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Raspberry
Hard Ice Cream

“so glad my son saw the location while we were driving 🍦🍨 very good!!“

4.6 Superb55 Reviews
The Fair Shake Ice Cream Shop • $
1509 Penna Ave, Pine City - 9.23 miles

“awesome staff and excellent ice cream!!!“

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Maple Lawn Dairy Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
3162 Lower Maple Ave, Elmira - 9.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Prime Rib Breakfast Burrito
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
Strawberry Shortcake
Maple Lawn Sundae
Traditional Wings
Corned Beef Hash
Belgian Waffle
Brownie Sundae
Blackened Fish

“The first restaurant I ever ate at that I left hungry. My friends and I go on my days off. I had not eaten all day. It is the only place that I can get liver and onions. The cook always does an amazing job. Just right, not tough. I'll recommend you every time for quality. I politely asked my server if I could order extra meat. I said I would GLADLY pay more if I could be accommodated. I was flatly told that she didn't see how that was possible, she couldn't see how she could bill for it. I was offered an extra salad if I was that hungry. My request was not forwarded to her supervisor or owner. This was on a Friday night and the place smelled amazing! I was there for the meat and my stomach was rumbling. I wasn't even offered the option to purchase two meals! I payed my bill, four adults and deserts. It was over $121.00. I left angry with myself that I barely tipped 10%. I am a generous tipper. Usually over 20%. Really! You let me leave there still hungry?“

4.4 Superb107 Reviews
King Kone Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1315 College Ave, Elmira - 3.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Twist with Sprinkles in a Cup and Cone
Ice Cream Cone
Hot Fudge

“So many flavors in cone
And their cones are massive !!!
They have a couple of pops for smaller kids and albeit expensive they are very tasty.
I recommend trying the vanilla cone with cherry dip because that’s what most people were ordering.
Since it was our first time here I had their green apple and caramel cone.
Very unique taste in soft cones.“

4.4 Superb48 Reviews
Big Top Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
2354 Corning Rd, Elmira Heights - 1.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Forest Sunday Cherry Toppings on a Brownie with Your Choice of Hard or Soft Ice Cream
Soft Serve with Rainbow Sprinkles
Strawberry Cheesecake
Hot Fudge Sundae
Hard Ice Cream
Whipped Cream
Piece of Cake
Cookie Dough

“Great place to get ice cream. Changing of soft flavors offers delicious variety. Everyone who works there is so nice and friendly!“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews

You May Also Like