7 Best Ice Cream Shops near Cortland

Frosty Caboose Ice Cream Shop • $
107 Homer Ave, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough Sundae Without Hot Fudge
Whipped Cream & Cherry
Onion Sauce
Blueberry

“Second visit to these guys and I would recommend them“

4.8 Superb60 Reviews
Poole's Drive-In Family • $
3033 NY-13, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Fish Fry Friday Dinner
Rodeo Burger w Fries
Hot Dog w Fries
Homemade Pies

“Pooles drive in is a lovely gem. Great food, atmosphere and service. The best fish sandwich you can find anywhere.“

4.7 Superb22 Reviews
Footie's Freez Ice Cream Shop • $
1041 McLean Rd, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Black Raspberry
Hard Ice Cream
Soft Serve
Strawberry

“Classic American mom and pop ice cream stand. There was a line of 10 or so people when I arrived, so patience is key.
I got a Texas hot with lemonade and some chips and a Lemon Cheesecake Bar ice cream, it was quite good.

Bring Cash. 👍“

4.5 Superb79 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
170 Clinton Ave, Cortland

Customers` Favorites

Legendary Honey BBQ Chicken Supermelt
Mint Cookie Crunch Sundae
Fried Shrimp with Fries
Nuts over Caramel Sundae
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Mac and Cheese Burger
Crispy Chicken Salad
Chicken Quesadilla

“I love this restaurant so clean and well maintained. The servers are always nice and on top of everything. Management is the best“

4.1 Good197 Reviews
Frosty Cow Ice Cream Shop • $
15 Livermore Crossing, Dryden - 7.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Sundae
Ice Cream Cone
Banana Split
Hot Fudge

“I love the place I’ll do anything to help the owner out if they need it any time great people good ice cream know what I want soo. I get there“

4.8 Superb53 Reviews
Super Cream Dairy Bar Ice Cream Shop • $
75 N West St, Homer - 3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Soft Serve with Rainbow Sprinkles in a Waffle Cone
Mint Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Marshmallow
Super Cream Banana Split
Hard Ice Cream in Cup
Chicken Tenders 5
Hot Fudge Sundae
Black Raspberry
Grilled Cheese
Ice Cream Cone
Soft Ice Cream

“We have always loved Super Cream Dairy Bar, but one visit will always be extra special to our family.
Last year, my daughter was very sick for a long time. She barely wanted to eat anything. One day she drew a picture of an ice cream cone with a pink scoop and a cherry on top and said, “I wish I could have an ice cream like this.”
I took her drawing with us to Super Cream and explained what she had imagined. The staff didn’t hesitate—they recreated her drawing almost perfectly. Seeing her face light up when they handed her an ice cream that looked just like her picture is a memory I’ll never forget 🥹. She still talks about “the ice cream from my drawing.”
What makes this place special isn’t just that one act of kindness. We don’t come looking for over-the-top creations with “unicorn dust from Mount Sinai.” 😄 Most of the time we order simple ice cream, spend time together as a family, and every single visit is consistently delicious. The ice cream is always fresh, the portions are generous, and the staff is genuinely friendly.
Thank you, Super Cream, for making an ordinary day unforgettable and for always serving great ice cream with a smile. ❤🍦“

4.5 Superb135 Reviews
So Good Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop •
5 N West St, Homer - 2.45 miles

“We had amazing treats here tonight, fun atmosphere too!“

3.6 Good17 Reviews

You May Also Like