Find
{{ group }}
{{ item.name }}
{{ item.address }}
{{ item.name }}
Near
{{ item.properties.formatted }}
SEARCH
NY
/
Eagle Bay
/
Cafe
/
The Bay Cafe and Market
The Bay Cafe and Market
CLOSED
$$ •
5561 NY-28, Eagle Bay
Menu
Menu
Photos
Location
Menu
Add a Menu
Photos
Add a Photo
View All Photos
People in Eagle Bay Also Viewed
Red Dog Tavern
Bar & Grill, American, Vegetarian
Mary's White Pine Bakery
Bakery, Vegetarian
Screamen Eagle / Matts Draft House
Pizza, Pet Friendly
Restaurants in Eagle Bay, NY
Location & Contact
5561 NY-28, Eagle Bay, NY 13331
Suggest an Edit
✕
Get more info in our app
Download the app for free
Open
Take-Out/Delivery Options
take-out
Nearby Restaurants
The Tavern
Bar & Grill, Dive Bar
Red Dog Tavern
Bar & Grill, American, Vegetarian
The Little Camp Café
Cafe
Mary's White Pine Bakery
Bakery, Vegetarian
Wine Shop
Bar, Beer, Wine & Spirits, Wine
You May Also Like
10 Weirdest Ice Cream Flavors Worth Trying
Oktoberfest in the USA
Burger King's Parent Company Plans to Open 1,800 New Restaurants a Year by 2028
Must-Try New Restaurants in New York City This Season
A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in New York City
Updated on:
Oct 04, 2026
