Cafes near Eagle Bay

The Bay Cafe and Market Cafe • $$
5561 NY-28, Eagle Bay

“Here's from some vegetarian, and one gluten-free vegetarian, and a kid, and a dedicated coffee snob: delicious, top to bottom! Iced Americano and hot chocolate, were excellent, omelettes, eggs, toast and home fries- fantastic! And, my hubby who loves sweets and is unfortunately gluten free, found the best peanut butter cookie and some little miracle called a "chocolate puddle"! All approve, and the gift shop upstairs has great, unique items- no lie!!“

0 Na0 Reviews
The Little Camp Café Cafe • $$
148 NY-28, Inlet - 1.47 miles

“We had reservations for six of us 5:30 on Sunday. The place was empty in the dining area. We unfortunately could not be seated in the enclosed deck area overlooking the lake because only parties of two or four were seated out there. What a shame as the views were stunning. I chose to order two appetizers for my dinner since I was not very hungry. I ordered the Original Tapas tray and the Stuffed Portobello Mushroom. My Honey ordered the Beet Salad. My Tapas consisted of three of Crab Rangoon, Fried Pork Dumplings and several Grilled Marinated Bourbon Steak and all were all very good. The Stuffed Portobello Mushroom was even better. Very tasty indeed. My Honey did not enjoy her Beet Salad as much, as her experience this time did not meet her expectations/memories of when she had before. Also there was not enough beets for her. The rest of our party seemed to enjoy the Grilled Prime Rib, the Salmon and Veal very much. Our server Alexis was very friendly, helpful and attentive. The gentleman that seated us didn't seem very friendly nor enthusiastic but that did not deter us. The place started receiving more diners as the evening went on. The adjacent room had a large private party celebrating a special occasion. The dinner was very Delicious and if we were able to be seated on the enclosed deck I would have given then a five rating. We were very happy with our choices and we recommend.“

3.5 Good2 Reviews