18 Best Sandwich Shops near East Amherst

“My husband and I, visited April 30, 2024 at 12:30pm and the gentleman working encompassed a mastery over the art of sub-making unlike anything we have ever experienced. He was nothing short of extraordinary and we will absolutely be visiting more frequently....only when he is working! “

“Good food and consistent. Nice service in addition. I recommend trying them, you will not be disappointed!!“

“Always fresh, the owners have kept the menu and quality in place“

“I love the service it's quick and easy to order and the subs are amazing I tried the turkey this time The subs are pretty big especially if you get everything on it but I'm a picky person so I only got turkey cheese tomato mayo oil“

“Always friendly staff when we have ordered and they always get our order correct. Miles better then the new jersey mikes location in Cheektowaga. You can definitely tell the difference in ownership and employees between the two. Just sad that we can no longer order delivery from this location.“

“Some of the best sandwiches around. By far! The spicy Cajun chicken and the Engineer are our favorite.“

“Went there for the first time and had a great experience and the food was Really good Two BIG thumbs up!!! 🤪“

“This place is amazing! They are friendly, accommodating and serve high quality food. I’ve only ordered take out, as it’s a favorite spot to grab lunch for meetings at work, but I bet they’re service is just as great at the restaurant.“

“What a neat discovery. I love soup any time of year so I was ready to try this. I had bean and ham and, unlike most places, the soup was served nice and hot. The soup was good, but my sandwich was fantastic. I had a #14 chicken sandwich with melted fontana and grilled portobello mushroom. It practically melted in my mouth. The sandwich was just the right size...I'm tired of massive overstuffed food. This was just right. I'll definitely be back next time in town.“

“Love how welcoming the staff were, the food was delicious, I got the cowboy (without bacon) on a 7in multigrain. Highly recommend!

You have many different bread options, the ingredients are fresh and the service was amazing!“

“My sub was absolutely terrible, but the employee who was working had such amazing service. I think his name was Aaron or something, I forgot lowkey but he was chill af. the cookies were good though so that was a plus. keep up the good service!“

“great customer service, sold me on the cherry pepper relish which made my sub better! thanks to the staff that served me on Aug 26th in the evening, you guys rocked it out when it got busy! I appreciate the lady who did the toppings for my sub, she's the one who sold me on the relish and rocked it out!“

“Natasha & Cedric gave me amazing service! They aimed to please and did just that!“

“There’s something to be said about a place that doesn’t chase every new trend but instead focuses on getting the fundamentals right—and this restaurant does just that. From the moment you walk in, there's an unpretentious charm. The ambiance isn’t trying too hard; it feels lived-in, in a comforting way, like it’s been part of the community for years.
Service was timely and polite. You won’t find over-the-top presentation here, but the warmth and attention to detail are very real. Our server remembered small requests and had a great sense of timing when it came to checking in.
The menu isn’t massive, which I see as a plus. They do fewer things, but they do them well. Everything we ordered came out exactly as described, and there’s a clear consistency in how the kitchen approaches flavor and preparation. Even the side dishes felt intentional.
There’s a casual rhythm to how everything flows—from the greeting at the door to the final check. It feels genuine and steady, which is why I’ve come to trust it as a go-to.
If you want a dependable place with character, one that won’t let you down, this one checks all the boxes.“

“Stopped in yesterday for lunch. This will be my Subway from now on!! Food was delicious. Veggies and meat super fresh!! The bread tasted like it just came out of the oven. The staff was incredibly kind. Thank you for this phenomenal experience!“

“This was my first time here, and WOW! I ordered the "Chairman of the Board" and it was fantastic. The turkey was tender & juicy. The roll was super fresh. It wasn't heavy in my stomach like fried food can be. People in my group also ordered a "How-You_Doin?" sangwich and "Hey Sonny!" burger. They were both very pleased and we all agreed that we wanted to order from this restaurant again soon. My order was ready pretty fast.“

“(Translated by Google) The sandwiches are excellent, each client has it assembled to their own liking. Too bad they didn't have coffee.(Original)Los sandwiches son excelentes, cada cliente lo hace armar a su propio agrado. Lástima que no tenían café.“