The Golden Pear Cafe

Name: The Golden Pear Cafe
Address: 34 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, New York, 11937, US
Telephone: (631) 329-1600
Price range: $$
Rating: 2.9

$$ •

Hours:
34 Newtown Ln, East Hampton
(631) 329-1600

Menu Order Online

About The Golden Pear Cafe

The Golden Pear Cafe is known for its consistently good iced coffee and tea, with many customers enjoying the cold brew. The sandwich options, like the Sag Harbor with chicken salad on ciabatta and coleslaw, are decent but not outstanding. Prices are considered high for East Hampton, and while the café has a cheerful ambience, some customers feel that the tables should be more attractive given the price. Despite the pleasant coffee smell, the high menu prices and occasional issues with bees outside may make some hesitant to return. One customer mentioned that a muffin and small iced tea cost $12, which seemed overpriced compared to nearby options.

Baked goods at the cafe look gorgeous but do not always match in taste, with some items like the apple turnover lacking apple and the muffins and scones described as dry. The coffee has been noted to be acidic, which may not appeal to everyone. There are also concerns about pricing discrepancies on the website; customers are advised to check with staff for accurate pricing. On a positive note, the Quinoa bagel is quite tasty, and the turkey chili and Mac and cheese receive high praise. The egg sandwiches are particularly popular, described as delicious and filling, with crispy bacon and a preference for sausage patties noted. The outdoor seating offers a nice spot for people-watching, making it a place worth returning to for some customers.