9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Ellicottville

“Every time I’ve ever been here it’s always such a great experience. Food is always amazing. Staff is so kind & accommodating. Atmosphere speaks for itself. Working in this industry I also love seeing the same faces months apart. Says a lot! :)“

“This place was great! From the greeting at the door by the friendly owner to the attentive waiter! Most delicious brick oven baked wings and pizza! The GF crust is hands down the best!“

“I’ve been going here since I was a kid, it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had and would always be so excited to go when we would drive down from Ontario, the best atmosphere and the best service. The owner would always come say hi and talk to us like family, haven’t been in a little bit but have always and will always love this place like a second home.“

“Typically I would recommend Tim & Bonnies in EVL but today’s meal was horrible. My Mom and I ordered the grilled chicken sub and my Dad ordered a tuna wrap. We sat, for what seemed like forever, waiting for our food. I remember commenting that there sounded like there was nothing going on in the kitchen a couple of times. Eventually, the grilled chicken subs were delivered. They were stone cold and the chicken was very crispy. It appeared that the chicken was not freshly cooked, but somewhat reheated for the sub? Definitely not appetizing! About 5 minutes after the subs were delivered my Dad’s wrap was delivered. I guess we didn’t want to eat together? There was one person waiting for a to go order in the store and no other customers that appeared to be waiting for food. My parents and I are locals to EVL and have done what we can to help give restaurants business during the pandemic. First by ordering to go and then coming into restaurants when we were able to but the service we received today was questionable at the least. I hope it improves.“

“Their food is always fresh and the delivery service is excellent. I highly recommend them.“

“Definitely a place to stop at in Salamanca New York. You’re always greeted with friendly people behind the counter. They are courteous and they’re fast and that pizza is always good. Definitely have to try the pizza with the pretzel crust. Oh my God it is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life, they said it was a special, so hurry up and get to Little Caesars and go get your pretzel crust. It was cheesy it was fresh and it was amazing!“

“We picked up dinner at Katys last night, enjoyed it so much we ordered it again for lunch today! We had 7 different menu items but our favorites were the alfredo crab stuffed haddock and the bbq chicken melt. We also couldn't believe the size of the Italian platter and the fry pile.“

“Beautiful building & property... amazing patio. Everything was delicious! One thing I'd do differently next time I order the calamari with the pomodoro separately from the perfectly fried calamari. Once they pile the calamari atop the tomato sauce it destroys that beautiful fried crust .. obliterates it.“