Restaurants near Fair Haven

The Barn at Wildwood Restaurant 14607 Cayuga St, Fair Haven Breakfast • $$
14607 Cayuga St, Fair Haven

Customers` Favorites

Eggs
Sausage Gravy over Home Fries or Biscuits
Sausage Gravy over Corned Beef Hash
Meat Lovers

“My wife and I came in from Syracuse on our way out to the lake and decided to try something new for breakfast and are EXTREMELY happy we did. The food was incredible. I got the Crosset house special of sausage gravy over home fries with over easy eggs, raisin toast and sausage patties. My wife got the Cricket #1 house special which is meat and cheese stuffed french toast and we ordered an additional half-order of corned beef hash. Everything about the food was fantastic. The home fries were savory and clearly cooked in the right amount of fat. Sausage gravy was homemade and perfect. Eggs cooked perfectly, bacon in the french toast was crispy and delicious. Even the coffee was perfect. The staff were all extremely nice and attentive and the owner stopped over to ask how everything was. We will absolutely be back. 10/10 on every aspect of our breakfast.”

4.9 Superb39 Reviews
Little Sodus Inn 14451 Bell Ave, Fair Haven Bar • $
14451 Bell Ave, Fair Haven

Customers` Favorites

Fried Green Beans

“Best dive bar in Fair Haven. Fantastic chicken wings. Boat in & dock your boat out back. Live music. Epic sunsets. Everyone is friendly & lively. Darts & jukebox. Not a craft beer destination, no IPAs. Makes me miss Mary.Parking: Overflow parking available nearby.”

4.5 Superb30 Reviews
Brandon's Pub + Grille 559 Main St, Fair Haven Irish Pub • $$
559 Main St, Fair Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Riggies
Black Jack Burger and Chips
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Pub Cheese Steak
Build a Burger

“We had kind of a large party show up for lunch. The staff were very helpful and genuinely cared about your order and how it was to be prepared.The menu could use a few more details to include things like mentioning that they would be using garlic aioli on a club sandwich. Sandwich was delicious but the garlic aioli wad unexpected and overwhelmed the entire taste of the sandwich including the bacon. I enjoy garlic aioli on some food items but it should have been mentioned on the menu... my grandchild was not a fan of garlic aioli but loves plain mayonnaise on her sandwich. We had to reorder the sandwich after everyone else was served and watch my 3-year-old wait while everyone else was eating. This could have been a non-issue had they only taken time to mention this small detail on the menu.Kid-friendliness: As I mentioned in my review we had to have a 3-year-old waitand have her food remade because of the ingredients. The staff bent over backwards to help keep her entertained during the wait for her meal. Made the whole ordeal not nearly as bad as it could have been. Any of us that have 3-year-old children or grandchildren know they are not the most patient people on the planet.”

4.5 Superb36 Reviews
Big Bo's 580-582 Main St, Sterling Ice Cream Shop • $
580-582 Main St, Sterling - 0.1 miles

“We stopped at Big Bo's for a ice cream cone after spending a nice day at the beach at Fairhaven State Park. Big Bos features Perry Ice cream. A small cone came with two large scoops. I highly reccomed the choclate mint. Creamy and delicious. Big Bo's offers picnic tables with shaded trees for your pleasure. Service was fast and friendly plenty of parking”

4.7 Superb75 Reviews
Sweets By Sarah Bakery 591 Main St, Sterling Bakery • $
591 Main St, Sterling - 0.06 miles

“...just wanted to say how amazing the pies you made for Hannibal school are...they looked fabulous & tasted delicious...you definitely know how to bake...I'll definitely be a repeat customer ???”

4.8 Superb41 Reviews
Cottage Inn Restaurant 13662 NY-370, Red Creek Pizza • $
13662 NY-370, Red Creek - 6.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Montreal Steak Topped with Mushrooms
Stuffed Chicken Riggies
9oz Prime Rib Special
Chicken Cordon Bleu
King Cut Prime Rib
Pork Chops Sinclas
Deep Fried Shrimp
Onion Soup

“We are new to Central New York, and The Cottage Inn is one of the very few "local" places with great selections, great food & the best service. Make sure you make reservations or you may have a wait, this is the local hot spot and is packed full on Friday & Saturday nights.We have tried many of the specials, and the seafood platter & prime rib are our favorites. There's also a great selection of adult beverages with a great "pub-like" atmosphere at the bar, and more than enough selections of dessert for that after dinner treat.You won't go wrong choosing The Cottage Inn for your next quiet dinner for two, or fill a table for 12, this place can accommodate all size groups.But call ahead, or you may wait for an open table... we recommend waiting if needed, you won't be disappointed.”

4.7 Superb41 Reviews
Foster's 12029 E Main St, Wolcott Diner • $
12029 E Main St, Wolcott - 8.69 miles

“A total gem of local charm and fantastic home cooking. If you're near Sodus, Fair Haven or Wolcott and you don't stop by for breakfast or lunch, you are really missing out. Run by great friendly people. Totally love it.”

4.7 Superb36 Reviews
Peter's New York Pizzeria 12013 E Main St, Wolcott Pizza • $$
12013 E Main St, Wolcott - 8.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Calzone
Garlic Knots
Sheet Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
House Special Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
BBQ Wings
Haddock

“We are some what new to wolcott and we have ordered a few times and we’re never disappointed but last night we ordered a couple deep dishes and man were they amazing it is really hard finding a great deep dish. You could tell the pizza was made with love ❤️ we will for sure be ordering again you have a new long time customer thank youFor the amazing pizza ?”

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
IOOB Club Chapter 3991 1770 Sand Hill Rd, Martville Bar
1770 Sand Hill Rd, Martville - 5.97 miles

“Private club not for profit keeps the costs down. You must be with a member and sign the book as a guest. Pool table, darts, Nascar, and touchtunes available. A nice woodstove for winter and daily lunch specials are all part of what makes it appealing to local members. I like the super bloody Marys on Sundays.”

4.7 Superb29 Reviews
The Village Grill of Fair Haven 809 NY-104A, Sterling Diner • $
809 NY-104A, Sterling - 0.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Corned Beef Hash

“I can't say enough good things about this restaurant, the menu options are vast and all the breakfast items we ate were awesome! The in-house made corned beef hash was delicious!”

4.7 Superb24 Reviews
Daphine's Diner 15085 NY 104, Martville Diner • $
15085 NY 104, Martville - 5.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Home Fries
Sandwich
Toast

“Random trip Google restaurant. Actually drove by turned around..looked and thought the worst. But need a restroom so went on inside . Used sit-down ordered. everything gotten was great and the staff were laid back , friendly and just positive to each table or customers.kinda like we were there 100s of times but very first time mistake.def will return in our routes ..”

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
Stick and Rudder 571 Main St, Sterling Pubs • $$
571 Main St, Sterling - 0.03 miles

“Very nice place to hang out and enjoy some craft beer or cocktails. I really like the layout with mixed seating. I didn't have any of the sharables, but they looked good. The bartender was very friendly. A great first impression.”

4.8 Superb14 Reviews
Malone's Irish Hideaway 271 Barker Rd, Oswego Bar & Grill • $
271 Barker Rd, Oswego - 7.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ruben Fries

“So this is the first time I have ever visited this bar. I went for a cornhole torney tonight and the set up they have is amazing. The bartenders were great. Overall it was a great first experience. If anyone feels like playing a great torney on Thursday evenings you should absolutely go. Love this place..”

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Sterling Cidery 14451 Richmond Ave, Sterling Cideries • $$
14451 Richmond Ave, Sterling - 0.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sampler

“Great place! We decided to stop in last minute. The owners are wonderful. Gave us a tour of his operation. We enjoyed all the ciders and his crabapple wine. We also tried a Hot Johnny. Highly recommended!”

4.6 Superb17 Reviews
ATM (Fastrac Markets) 5666 Whiskey Hill Rd, Wolcott Cafe • $
5666 Whiskey Hill Rd, Wolcott - 9.3 miles

“Bright and clean gas station/convenience store. I stop here often on road trips as it's a great place to get gas, use the bathroom, and get whatever drinks or snacks I need for the rest of the trip. Hot food is available (the cheese pizza is surprisingly good), as well as every cold drink you can think of. Grab and go foods like egg salad and deli meat sandwiches. There is a large hot drink station with coffee, cappuccino, hot chocolate, and tons of creamers and ways to flavor your drink. On Fridays in October, they are offering one free coffee per customer. Yay!”

5 Superb5 Reviews
Village Restaurant 6014 New Hartford St, Wolcott Family • $
6014 New Hartford St, Wolcott - 8.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ham
English Muffin
Steak Eggs
Home Fries
Hash Omelet
Eggs and Hash
Melted Cheese
Western Omelet
Big Bird with Bacon and Onion
Steak and Cheese Omelet

“Nice local restaurant with large varied menu. Friendly staff and decent prices. My husband and I ate lunch there and both loved our meals. Delicious soup! Nothing fancy but nice place!!”

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
The Village Tavern Hannibal 174 Oswego St, Hannibal Family • $
174 Oswego St, Hannibal - 6.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan

“Seen the place has been packed lately. Decided to order some take out. Steak and REAL potatoes was very delicious! All the food we ordered was good. All the workers I encountered down there were friendly.”

4.1 Good16 Reviews
Cornerstone Restaurant & Bar 6805 Main St, Red Creek American
6805 Main St, Red Creek - 4.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings with Mild Sauce

“This place is a hidden gem!!! Food is great, service is great and the owners are awesome! You MUST order the broaster chicken wings, or any food including the broaster chicken!!! It is 10x better than KFC. It is a very clean place!!! More people need to know about this! They should advertise!!”

4.2 Good43 Reviews
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina 356 King Rd, Sterling American • $$
356 King Rd, Sterling - 0.21 miles

“Excellent food and very nice outside dining. Great service. Try the 1/2 pound "Cowboy Burger" bacon, burger, cheese, peppers, and onion rings. W tator tots. $13.00 very good.Plenty of free parking. Straight walk to the deck from the parking lot for wheelchair use.”

4.2 Good147 Reviews
Colloca Estate Winery 14678 W Bay Rd, Sterling Wineries • $$
14678 W Bay Rd, Sterling - 1 miles

“Beautiful place!! Gorgeous chandeliers, clean ladies bathroom, nice water view. First time visiting Colloca for the New Years celebration. It was well organized, well decorated, the food and appetizers were delicious. The package also included the coffee bar and a glass of champagne at midnight. The music during dinner was pleasant and DJ for dancing was fun. All the guests were respectful and everyone had a great time. The price package was reasonable for New Years; however, there was a cash bar, which I thought the drinks were a bit high priced. The staff were attentive. It is located closer to Oswego, which it was a better option to us, instead going to Syracuse. I definitely recommend Colloca for New Years event if they are promoting again in 2024-2025. I'm looking forward to visit this place on the summer months. Thanks Colloca team for a fun New Years party!”

4.2 Good163 Reviews
China King Chinese Restaurant 6011 New Hartford St #2, Wolcott Chinese
6011 New Hartford St #2, Wolcott - 8.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sesame Chicken
Chicken or Roast Pork Lo Mein
Vegetable Chow Mein
Sesame Beef
Hot

“The chicken and mushrooms with lo mein is kickin.We recently ordered Chinese when we were in the city and it really made us appreciate how great our local Chinese place is. Food is awesome. Especially the lo mein and mei fun.Update:Today, we ordered the fried scallops and they were great.House special soup was jam packed with meat and veggies and delicious.The shrimp with Chinese vegetables have a TON of huge shrimp and is delicious.I'm always so happy with the food.”

3.8 Good14 Reviews
Ray Ray’s Pizza Shop 12047 E Main St, Wolcott Pizza • $$
12047 E Main St, Wolcott - 8.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch

“My grandsons and I had lunch, pizza slices and chicken fingers with Bar-B-Q sauce, we enjoyed it all. Best $20 ever.Kid-friendliness: Has booster seats and high chair if needed.”

3 Average29 Reviews
McDonald's 5658 Whiskey Hill Rd, Wolcott Fast Food • $
5658 Whiskey Hill Rd, Wolcott - 9.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fries
Double Quarter Pounder with Cheese
Spicy Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Fruit N Yogurt Parfait
Happy Meal Hamburger
Chicken Mcnuggets
Cheeseburger
Mcgriddles
Hashbrown
Croissant

“We got really great service and had supper and dessert for a great price. We have recently been in two other McD's and Wolcott is better in all areas mentioned above. They have greatly improved and work hard in all of these areas. We enjoy eating there.”

2.6 Average68 Reviews
map Map