Bella's Sicilian Ristorante
CLOSED$$ •
About Bella's Sicilian Ristorante
Bella's Sicilian Ristorante Reviews
275 ratings
We were in Geneva for the first time for one night only and luckily found this gem through a Google search. Tricia, our waitress, was warm and walked us through the menu. All the sauces, meatballs and sausages are made onsite. It made choosing very difficult! Our table chose lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs arrabbiata , and penne in vodka sauce. Warm bread was plentiful. Every dish was delicious and more than we could eat (they do offer the option to split a plate for a small...read full review
Last night I had a group on nine Canandaigua friends together for dinner at Bella’s Sicilian Ristorante. We’ve been friends for about 50 years. Other than my wife and me no one else had been there before. Well, as I expected, they all want to return, whether as a group or on their own. They all found their meals to be fabulous, service by our server Susan was attentive and friendly, and last but not least they enjoyed listening to and joining Tomas in song. Thank you Tomas,...read full review
Honestly really disappointed, I was there back in May, and all of our food was not good. Not what I had 3 years ago, mildly incompetent server. (Couldn't understand i wanted another cocktail and never got it) did recive the bill tho! Not worth it. All 4 of us had less than impressive meals. I paid for everything since I ranted and raved about this place all for myself to be embarrassed with a large bill. We even mentioned the food wasn't great server replied "yeah we know, we...read full review
Bella's Sicilian Ristorante in Geneva, NY is a popular spot for Italian cuisine. Their greens and beans dish is a standout, leaving diners craving more. The prices are reasonable, making it a must-visit for a peaceful meal. Service is attentive and prompt, creating a pleasant dining experience. Guests enjoy dishes like chicken caprese and fish fry, which receive high praise. All sauces, meatballs, and sausages are made onsite, adding to the authenticity. Warm bread is plentiful, and the dessert case offers fresh locally made treats, including a heavenly lemon cake. The restaurant has a cozy, old school vibe, and while some guests have experienced less satisfying meals, many find the food excellent and the prices inexpensive. It’s recommended to make a reservation to avoid waiting for a table and to try their Friday special before it sells out.