New American Restaurants in Geneva, NY

“The absolute best restaurant around- and by around I mean most of NY. This place is extraordinary in both food and service, and it is impossible to be disappointed here. I promise- try it. You’re welcome.“

“The food is outstanding! Super fresh, local ingredients, cooked properly. Ordered the specials of the day: grilled rainbow trout and ribeye with potatoes. The ingredients itself was so high quality-beef that tasted super beefy, medium rare done at exactly medium rare… the sides… the sauces… nothing was overly seasoned or salty, all the accompaniments were done well. Ordered seasonal local veggies as an appetizer… omg, so fresh, so good! Atmosphere is comfortable and airy, service so nice and friendly!“

“The experience was incredible. The knowledge of the staff, service and food was impeccable‼️🥰❤️❤️We will be backl‼️“

“Love this place and the ladies behind the bar are excellent at what they do!“

“excellent food and service“

“Do NOT miss out on this gem of a quick eatery and pub hang out! My friend and i had traveled from out of state, it was late and we were hungry and exhausted. Even though it was close to closing we were welcomed in by the main bartender Blake and Angie who was in training. She did great btw. The chef Juan was out in the main area since it was late and gave us not only great recommendations for our food but also for our trip around the wine trail we had planned for tomorrow. We both had sandwiches with their roast beef. The meat was tender and flavorful and the bread was so good! Our meal really hit the spot after such a long day and what made it even better was the amazing and welcoming service we received. If you live in Geneva, make this your regular hangout!!!“

“Best fish fry in town!!! Great food, great service and amazing atmosphere.“

“This was my first visit to Bellhurst Castle. I'd heard about it for years but never went until now. My husband had the Toasted Italian Panini and was very satisfied with it. I had the Grilled Chicken Caprese. It tasted great with a mix of chicken, pesto mayo, balsamic dressing, tomatoes on a toasted garlic bun. Just a fair warning, it's messy and the bun got soggy. Dessert was scrumptious. It was a chocolate chip cake and I would recommend it. The atmosphere felt a bit stuffy with dark walls and carpeting. We ate at the bar and I thought they had the most comfortable bar chairs I've experienced. Yes, it was pricey. Over $60 before tip.“