Forest Avenue Pizza

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours today·

About Forest Avenue Pizza

Forest Avenue Pizza is a family-owned restaurant that serves fresh, homemade-style dishes in a warm and friendly atmosphere. The restaurant is known for its great food, including the signature grandma's pizza, baked clams, and a popular Tuesday night pasta special. The menu also features the egg and pepper hero, meatball slice/hero, zeppolis, and a gluten-free pizza. With a big parking lot, wheelchair accessibility, and a kid-friendly environment, it's a top spot for families and locals. Customers praise the attentive and friendly service, describing the experience as feeling like being at their aunt and uncle's place. The energy is incredible, and Sal and the whole crew take real pride in what they do. Customers say they keep coming back for more.

Menu

Add a Menu
Forest Avenue Pizza Menu
Forest Avenue Pizza Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Forest Avenue Pizza
Forest Avenue Pizza
View All Photos

Forest Avenue Pizza Reviews

4.5
136 ratings
5
75%
4
6%
3
4%
2
4%
1
11%
Food
4.3
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about Forest Avenue Pizza

We have been going here as a family for years! The pizza is great and always fresh. The staff is also very nice and friendly. Such a nice staple to Glen Cove!
Every Long Islander has their pizza spot. This is mine from when they were across the street next to Edward's Grocery store.
I ordered a gluten-free pizza for a friend as well as a slice of regular pizza for me. She said it’s one of the best gluten-free she ever had and I also agree that the pepperoni slice was delicious large had enough pepperonis and was very good. The nice man at the front also made the experience worth it, looking forward to going back this weekend when I’m in town.

Read All Reviews(135)

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 10:15AM - 9:15PM
Wednesday 10:15AM - 9:15PM
Thursday 10:15AM - 9:15PM
Friday 10:15AM - 9:15PM
Saturday 10:15AM - 9:15PM
Sunday 10:15AM - 9:15PM
Updated on: