18 Best American Restaurants near Great Valley

“We were tourists looking for a breakfast/lunch spot and boy did we hit the jackpot. I had the best steak and eggs I've ever had, the server was so friendly and helpful and everyone at our table was happy and so full from the generous servings!! Thank you❤️“

“Good selection, good service, has hot food, and cold drinks. What else could one need from a country store!?!? Minutes away from either Holiday Valley, Holimont, Down town EVL, historic Salamanca, and the local hit spot, the Seneca Allegany Casino and Resort!“

“This is a great complement to the usual bars and grills around town. I would definitely go back for date night. Decent amount of vegetarian options on the menu. The cauliflower was solid, as was the hummus. Mushroom pizza was good. Would definitely return.“

“Stayed at Seneca Allegheny Casino and decided to try Myers for a local dining experience. Our Friday evening reservation went smoothly, and our welcoming server provided excellent recommendations for both the meal and wine.Myers has a charming, older décor that feels uniform and tasteful. The cleanliness was evident throughout-tables, floors, and dining ware were all well-maintained.Now, onto the highlight- the food! From shared appetizers to individual apps, soup, salad, and entrées, every item was outstanding. The bacon blue burger and seared tuna app were particularly noteworthy. The handmade onion rings and sweet potato waffle fries were a hit, and the French onion soup stood out with its deep, flavorful broth and well-chosen cheese topping.Traveling from Rochester, NY, for the weekend, we didn't just come for Myers, but it's safe to say we'll plan future trips to the area specifically for dining at Myers.“

“Food and service were really good here. There was no wait. The place is a little small I had actually passed by it while looking for it. It is worth the stop. I had the coconut shrimp with fries. The shrimp was delicious and done just right. The fries were the best! My partner had a cheeseburger and said it was very good. The waiter was friendly and helpful. I recommend giving this place a try!“

“Fusion is one of our favorite places to eat in Olean/Allegany or anywhere! It was the obvious choice for our wedding caterer. Aaron and Mary were so helpful in the planning process and made our ideal menu a reality. It was a very low stress process leading up to the wedding and on the wedding day. They were so considerate of my allergies and guest allergies. They accommodated our no frills, state park venue. They made a beautiful presentation and the food was delicious as always. I’m so glad that Fusion could be part of our day! Highly recommend for your catering needs!“

“Came in for a couple drinks and Allison was bartending, she’s always smiling, attentive and extremely kind always! Never a single complaint, and makes my drinks the way I like them any time I need it! Would love to see her bartending more!!!“

“We walked in for the first time ever and were treated with a ton of hospitality. The food was off the hook good... they made a slamming fried mushroom. In fact all of the fried food was good. They have a special wing sauce I think it's called blarney sauce. that I truly recommend trying it. I think sauce won an award. The staff took good care of us and treated us like family. We went back the next week and were greeted like Norm on cheers. My fiance and I were very impressed and consider it our new favorite place to watch the bills game. They put out a spread for the patrons which included finger foods like wings. They also have lice music there. The staff is a good looking bunch and one of the bar maids sings classic rock with another gentleman who plays the guitar. They have a great energy together. The crowd it draws is local friendly and welcoming. I would recommend stopping in to anybody. It's a hidden gem.Parking: There is limited parking on the parking lot but there is parking along the street“

“First time visiting the Park restaurant in 20 years of staying at Allegheny state park. The server was very courteous and kind. The food was delicious and at a good price. I had the cowboy burger, it was huge and the beef had great flavor. My son had the wings, and being a Buffalo NY native I have to say they were delicious. 10/10 will return next time I stay at Allegheny.Kid-friendliness: The server was so kind to my talkative little boy. He also made sure that he had all his leftovers packed for him as his eyes were bigger than his stomach ?“

“This is the lodge I prefer of the lodges offered at Holiday Valley. I like the bar area upstairs, but one bartender might lead to a little of a wait. Great bartenders when they get to you.You can get you lift ticket here.Plenty of room to sit and eat.Fire places on the main floor and upstairs.There is a store to purchase clothing and ski accessories.The food is fine for quick finger and American style food , ie burgers, fingers, fries, and pizza.“

“This is not a fine dining experience but the Wildwood knows exactly what it is and hits it out of the park. I haven't had a bad thing off their menu; fish, wings, burgers are all worthy of getting again and again. Their wing night is phenomenal especially with their affordable beer prices and wing flavors are great. Only downfall is that it's not open every day of the week.“

“Stopped there for lunch ; had a burger that came with fries and soup or salad; had the tortilla soup; portion was a full size bowl and delish! Burger was great too; fries a bit salty; waitress was very attentive and friendly; would highly recommend this place and prices were good“

“Great local bar with a family home feel . Always need to stop at Randys when in the area . There us always a great good special and the drinks are always cold. We went on a Friday and had the lemon pepper broiled fish fry , which was one of the best I've ever had and these onion ring are the absolute best in the world . If your in the area make Randys a must stop“

“I selected this place due to the high reviews. The atmosphere is fantastic and the staff were very attentive. The place was clean and welcoming. Sadly we both ordered the seafood boil. It is the first time I have ever added salt to a meal when dining out. Not a huge fan of salt, but there was little flavor. Hoping this was just a fluke by what we ordered. Also odd for an Italian restaurant not to offer bread or homemade pasta. Will keep a decent rating in case it was that particular dish.“

“Ok so unfortunately I have not gone to restaurant yet, however I have tried several of the beers. This is the Strawberry Crunch Bar. It is a nice crisp light beer, to me.I would definitely love it on hot summer day. Now that being said I am not much of a beer drinker. I do like this one.“

“We were in the mood for a pizza on this rainy day, while staying in Allegany State Park. We could not find a pizzeria in Salamanca so decided to give this restaurant a chance. We were surprised at the reasonable prices and at how good the supreme pizza was!“

“I was blown away by this place. We were visiting the area on a trip and this was one of two options that were open since ski season is over. As a result, I had low expectations. It ended up being fantastic. The Ellicottville Brewing Blueberry wheat ale I had was one of the best beers I've had in my life. Perfect amount of blueberry flavor, super smooth. I ordered a cheeseburger and it was also one of the best I've ever had. Cooked perfectly, great taste. They had live music while we there as well, but not overbearing at all. Just a guy and an acoustic guitar playing various classic rock songs. Just a really great vibe here. We will definitely be returning at some point.“

“My husband and I needed somewhere tasty and warm to get dinner after a long day out cross-country skiing.We didn’t expect to be able to get into Dina’s because we hadn’t set a reservation and it was a Saturday evening/night.But we were able to be seated right away despite busyness, and we promptly ordered a pizza to share along with a glass of wine each.The service was very caring/attentive, the food was great, and I certainly recommend giving them a visit!“