18 Best American Restaurants near Allegany

“Love the atmosphere,best burgers anywhere!!!“

“Veggie wontons were light and super crispy with just the right amount of sweet and spice with the dipping sauce. The fish tacos and the pork tacos were perfect, and we especially liked the tang of that pickled cabbage with the fish. The staff was attentive and the atmosphere was really nice! We will be back.“

“Some of the best food around. We were there yesterday for Christmas and the bartender/waitress that was working at noon was awesome.“

“My wife grew up in Olean, but she had not been back in almost 30 years. I’ve heard so many stories about how great the beef was, so when we visited Olean this past week, I knew that Beef’ N Barrel would be our first stop.

The experience was better than I had expected. What a great atmosphere. You could tell that this was a popular restaurant for locals, but an out of towner like myself was made to feel welcome. Our server was so friendly. One of the owners, PJ, went out of his way to make our dining experience outstanding.

Let’s get to the food. We had pickle chips for an appetizer. They were really good. The breading was a little thicker than some other pickle chips I’ve had. Main course was the beef on weck. The beef almost melted in my mouth. It was so good. PJ comped our dessert, so we ordered chocolate mud pie and strawberry shortcake ala mode, which was the weekly special. Fantastic.

We were in Olean for three days. There are plenty of places to eat, but we decided to go back to Beef’ N Barrel a second time before leaving town. It’s that good! The second time was just as good as our first visit.“

“Went there for the first time this week. The food was wonderful and so was the service! Large portions and very reasonably priced. We will be going back very soon!“

“1st time today while we were at Strolean. Let me tell you the amazing food but the service was over the top!!!! the server listen to all our special needs having 3 hot hungry kids who don't like the same thing but all wanted taco pizza!!!! they took the time kept all the toppings on sides!! our cups never went dry!!!! the chicken wing pizza was amazing never had it before w celery on top. the cheese bread has to be the best around!!!! we will be ordering from here again very soon now that we tried it!!!“

“👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍“

“One of the best kept secrets in the area! Beautiful venue. Amazing team to work with. Awesome food! Such a great time!! We love it here!“

“Just wanted to Thank You for hosting the Lighter Palooza group Saturday night . The staff was awesome and the food was Top Notch. Thank you and hope to see you soon .“

“Best grilled prime rib I've ever had in my life. Everything was wonderful thank you Sam.“

“I stopped there for lunch yesterday. I had the Rodeo Burger. It was the best burger I have ever had! 1/2 pound burger topped with two golden onion rings, sauce, and home made mesquite potato chips on the side. If you are looking for a great meal, check them out.“

“Always been happy with there food. staff and delivery.“

“Great place friendly workers“

“Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and always excellent food! The Manhattan clam chowder was crazy good.“

“Great food! Stopped there on a whim and what a pleasant surprise. Staff was fun, food was great (try the chocolate cake) and atmosphere was cool! I can always tell when a restaurant has a real chef, and the quality of food and presentation said it all. Go there, you'll love it!“

“The food was absolutely amazing! Bourbon wings, Ruben with Cajun fries and the fried pickles are the best! The spicy ranch dressing puts the pickles over the edge! We will be back!“

“There’s a blonde lady here who is absolutely amazing. She remembered everything I had eaten and ordered, down to the smallest details. We came back a week later, and nothing had changed—everything was exactly right, and she even remembered all the details about me and everyone else with me.

I’ve never experienced anything like this before. I sometimes struggle when ordering because my English isn’t very good, and it can be difficult for me to explain everything again and again. Now, there’s someone here who knows me—and knows us.

Thank you so much for your amazing service. I really appreciate it.“

“Was so good! We decided to come back today after eating here yesterday. Both days meals were absolutely divine, pancakes are the fluffiest I've ever had. Lattes were extremely good too. And the meal pictured was so good there were no scraps left. Definitely the best breakfast place around here. Highly recommend!“