10 Best American Restaurants near Allegany

“Fusion is one of our favorite places to eat in Olean/Allegany or anywhere! It was the obvious choice for our wedding caterer. Aaron and Mary were so helpful in the planning process and made our ideal menu a reality. It was a very low stress process leading up to the wedding and on the wedding day. They were so considerate of my allergies and guest allergies. They accommodated our no frills, state park venue. They made a beautiful presentation and the food was delicious as always. I’m so glad that Fusion could be part of our day! Highly recommend for your catering needs!“

“Great local bar with a family home feel . Always need to stop at Randys when in the area . There us always a great good special and the drinks are always cold. We went on a Friday and had the lemon pepper broiled fish fry , which was one of the best I've ever had and these onion ring are the absolute best in the world . If your in the area make Randys a must stop“

“This is one of the most popular restaurants in Olean. They don't take reservations, so be prepared to stand in line, especially on Friday & Saturday evenings. The food is excellent and the atmosphere is relaxing. You can't go wrong here!!“

“Best grilled prime rib I've ever had in my life. Everything was wonderful thank you Sam.“

“We had our Christmas party there. It was so much fun. I love the way they had us seated. Everyone could talk and be heard. The food was great. I had the chicken and bisque. It was delicious. I will definitely order it again. Thank you Liberty Tavern for a great Christmas party.“

“Great list when it comes to ice cream. Never seen so many desserts, so many options and choices. what's the menu was a little bigger in the prices, saying a little steep. answer the atmosphere. Is very family friendly book a news from work on the cleaning part.“

“Had the Beer Battered Fish Fry with coleslaw and onion rings with petal sauce….Absolutely fantastic, fish was tender and moist without being greasy. Great flavor in the coleslaw good balance of acidity. Petal sauce was perfect. Waitress was super friendly and service was very quick…only took about 10-15 mins after ordering for food to be served. Highly recommend.“

“Chris and Payton did an outstanding job. Service was spot on and top notch. They were both on top of their game, and checked on us frequently even during the dinner rush to make sure we were all good. The food came out just as we ordered, perfectly cooked, and delicious. My son is always a picky eater and he ate every bite so that says a lot for us as parents to his approval. We will be back for sure.“

“Love supporting local and this was just another one of those experiences of a locally owned and operated restaurant. The proof is in the quality of the food and presentation. The steak sandwich was over the top tender and full of flavor and the wings were crispy and delicious . They even came with celery on the side ! We also had the nachos with chicken which were excellent as well . Not to mention the great service from the waitress and staff. Highly recommend this restaurant if you're in the area:-)“

“Stopped in on a random Friday afternoon, new to the area but my fiancé knows the owner. Has since been sold to the son. Had an amazing time talking to both of them. As someone who has gone through an exact situation, it was heartwarming to see that their legacy is still going strong. Highly recommend the stuffed peppers appetizer and the fish sandwich“