Restaurants near Henderson

Carbone's Waterside Restaurant 13471 County Rte 123, Henderson Pizza • $$
13471 County Rte 123, Henderson

Customers` Favorites

Meatballs
Calamari
Local Beef Burger with Fries
Waterside Clam Chowder
Soup of the Day Bowl
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Riggies
Lobster Roll
Fish N Chips
Crab Cake

“We visited Saturday evening for a birthday dinner with a party of 7! The food was amazing and our waiter was very accommodating and all his recommendations were spot on. We all tried something different so we could share our plates. The salmon dinner and the shrimp scampi was my favorite! The calamari with the roasted peppers was amazing. We will definitely be visiting again this summer. The evening weather and view was perfect for the back deck and the expresso martini was even better yet! 🍸 🍤 ☀️ 🎉”

4.7 Superb151 Reviews
Cherry Tree Inn 8541 State Rte 3, Henderson Family • $
8541 State Rte 3, Henderson

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Skillet
French Toast
Burger
Eggs over Easy Bacon Whole Wheat Toast
Sausage Gravy Benedict
Western Egg Sandwich
Toast and Home Fries
Country Fried Steak
Breakfast Sandwich
Garbage Omelette

“Had a great breakfast at Cherry Tree Inn. It was packed on a Sunday morning; lucky for me I was dining solo and could eat at the counter. Had a great pancake and eggs breakfast cooked perfectly. My coffee cup was never empty. Price was reasonable ($13.50 plus tip) considering what restaurants are charging now. I probably will be back again tomorrow for breakfast.”

4.7 Superb143 Reviews
Trolley Ice Cream 8355 State Rte 3, Henderson Ice Cream Shop • $
8355 State Rte 3, Henderson

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Swirl
Strawberry Ice Cream With
Almond Raspberry
Piece of Cake
Butter Pecan
Baby Twist

“Family tradition to stop at the Trolley on Mother's Day after walking the beach at Southwicks. Today's top pick was the caramel praline turtle. Yum!! Of course a well enjoyed doggy ice cream for Daisy May. Great service with a friendly smile, Looking forward to having our summer ice cream stops at the Trolley... 🌟🌟🌟🌞🌟🌟🌟”

4.2 Good128 Reviews
Chrissy Beanz Bakery & Café - Sackets Harbor 105 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor Cafe • $
105 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 7.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bakery
Drip Coffee
Croissant
Muffins
Toast with Butter Jelly or Peanut Butter
Orange Creamsicle Smoothie
Scrambled Egg Breakfast
Breakfast Burrito
Toasted Challah
Brewed Coffee

“The shaken espresso is my go to !!! great staff and phenomenal, bake goods, especially the crème brûlée 🤍☕️”

4.8 Superb202 Reviews
The Sandwich Bar 113 W Main St, Sackets Harbor Sandwich Shop • $
113 W Main St, Sackets Harbor - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Vanilla Ice Coffee
Grown Up Grilled Cheese
Breakfast Sandwiches
Breakfast Wrap
The Garrison
Chips
Pesto
Soda

“The Owner is awesome lady!!”

4.8 Superb160 Reviews
Lakeside Eatery 104 Bartlett Rd, Sackets Harbor Pizza • $$
104 Bartlett Rd, Sackets Harbor - 7.93 miles

“Just got our pizza and wings delivered. AWESOME!! Pizza was hot and fresh!! Plenty of toppings. Wings were fingerlicking good!! We'll be back for sure!! Nicky & Bob McMullen”

5 Superb12 Reviews
Bubbly Scoops 208 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor Bubble Tea
208 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 7.59 miles

“Very hip, modern shop, stepping in another world…. Excellent job! 🥂⚓️”

4.7 Superb23 Reviews
The Barracks Inn Restaurant & Bar 42 Pike Rd, Sackets Harbor French • $$$
42 Pike Rd, Sackets Harbor - 8.14 miles

“The Barracks Inn hosted the Sackets Harbor prom in May 2022, and it was an amazing experience for all! Kim was so easy to work with, and she went above and beyond to make the night special for our students. When I asked them what they enjoyed most, they replied: - The view of the water was beautiful. - The sunset was amazing. The space, itself, was great because it allowed us to move around and dance, but then we could move to a different space and a have conversation. - Dessert was delicious! The boba was amazing! Thanks you again for making prom so much fun for our students!”

4.8 Superb82 Reviews
Nu Pier Restaurant 13212 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor American • $
13212 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor - 6.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Absolutely
Fish Fry
Lake Effect Snow Burger
Scrambled Eggs
Chicken Wings
Egg Omelette
Roast Beef
Home Fries
Reuben

“Always friendly staff ♥️ just great people ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

4.3 Superb169 Reviews
The Parlor 119 W Main St, Sackets Harbor Ice Cream Shop
119 W Main St, Sackets Harbor - 7.5 miles

“Little ice cream shop along West Main Street in Sackets! Very close to Goodfello’s. Perfect for this summer weather! They are open until 10pm & only takes cash. Amazing staff as well ♥️”

4.3 Superb12 Reviews
Papa Tino's Pizzeria II 213 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor Pizza • $
213 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 5.42 miles

“Absolutely delicious, friendly staff”

4.1 Good41 Reviews
The Whiskey Coop 214 1/2 W Main Street, Sackets Harbor Chicken • $$
214 1/2 W Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 7.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

BBQ
Duck Wings
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Big Bird
The Dirty Bird
Hot Mess
Pickle Rick
Cluck Norris
Cheesecake Brownie Sundae Derby Pie
Chicken Wings

“Awesome lunch, food was hot and their potato chips are the best!”

4.2 Good232 Reviews
13

Subway

Subway 13821 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor Sandwich Shop • $
13821 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor - 7.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

White Chip Macadamia Nut
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Oven Roasted Turkey
Lays Baked Original
Meatball Marinara
Grilled Chicken
Subway Club
Potato Chip
Roast Beef
B L T

“Cut it close with the last 4 sub rolls on a Tuesday 7pm visit, so caution there, It would be nice to have packets of Oil & Vinegar along with the Mayonnaise, ans/ or Italian dressing. It's nice to take a dry sub on an excursion and add toppings at time of eating so the bread isn't soggy.
Suggestion.....”

3.8 Good64 Reviews
Good Fellos 202 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor Pizza • $$
202 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 7.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ravioli
Sauce
Creme Brulee
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fettuccine Bolognese
Smoked Duck Wontons
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Riggies
Margherita Pizza
Jeremiah Pizza

“Really good service and food”

4.1 Good356 Reviews
Pennocks Icecream 13162 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor Ice Cream Shop • $
13162 State Rte 3, Sackets Harbor - 6.61 miles

“Pennocks has been a staple for our annual family trip to the cottage. They have many flavors and are friendly. As a PSA, bring cash. This is a small seasonal business and they do not take cards. The Dollar General across the street is a good place to get cash if needed. Support this wonderful local business! Great people, great ice cream.”

3.6 Good51 Reviews
The Sackets Boathouse 214 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor American • $$
214 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 7.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hamburger
Blackened Chicken Alfredo
Maryland Crad Dip
Fried Fish Tacos
Boathouse Chips
Shrimp Linguine
Coconut Shrimp
Lobster Roll
Shrimp Pasta
Fish & Chips

“My family had a great lunch there yesterday. Food and the view were wonderful, our server Jillian was amazing! She was super friendly, went above & beyond!! 👏🏻Tell Jillian she rocks!🍋‍🟩”

4 Good263 Reviews
Tin Pan Galley 110 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor American • $$
110 West Main Street, Sackets Harbor - 7.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed French Toast
Lobster Roll
French Onion Soup
Creme Brulee French Toast
Huevos Rancheros
Thai Steak Salad
Sea Scallops
Reuben Omelet
Scallop Dinner
Breakfast Sandwich on a Croissant w Homefries

“Nice place but plan on waiting for EVER!!!! to get your food”

3.6 Good385 Reviews