9 Best Italian Restaurants near Homer

“Their crust tastes delicious, and they have so many options for toppings! Always ready within the time they say, always friendly staff, and just great all around pizza place!“

“Wow! Amazing chicken Caesar salad! Good price and ready quickly. So good. Highly recommend!👍“

“The Sweet Basil in Tully is one of my favorite places to eat. The food is absolutely delicious, great selection of beer, efficient staff and an all around great place to eat. A huge shout out to this family owned husband and wife team that has consistently maintained the quality of their food, maintained their standards all through the pandemic, definitely 5 star recommendation.“

“Can't believe last night was the first time I actually ate here. 5 stars across the board....three people for dinner and everyone agreed the food was excellent!! Service was outstanding from being seated, to ordering and receiving our meals. Portions were enough that I brought half of mine home to have the next day. Thanks for a great dining experience, will definitely be back.“

“The food is delicious. Probably the best restaurant we've dined at in Cortland thus far for Italian food. The ingredients are fresh. Their sauce is probably in the top five restaurants for tomatoe sauces I've had when dining out anywhere. The desserts are delicious. The prices on the menu, the quality, and the portions of the food are on point. Everything was cooked perfect except the choice in garnish (imo). I love cilantro but not on Italian dishes. Not sure if it was a mistake or trying something different than most other Italian restaurants. Cilantro is delicious but there are some people who do not like it. It's an acquired taste therefore it may not be the best choice of garnish for that type of cuisine because that type of ingredient isn't expected in my opinion. We'll be back hoping that the food is just as good as this time, only next time when bringing a party of four I've made a note to request not to be seated at a booth that is meant for a party of two.“

“Why a meal my husband and I had today the steak was just cooked how we wanted it. The service was great and I’ve never had before. It’s called honey cake that will satisfy anybody’s sweet tooth around. I recommend it for friends and family. Great job, everyone.“

“Absolutely delicious. Spaghetti sauce was outstanding best sauce around. Steak was tender and flavorful. And each side was delicious that came with the meals. Definitely will be back.“

“Good .... this is a very well established local bar that's one of the oldest in our community and popular with a specialized segment of the population! Well worth supporting history in the hint that it will be born again sometime soon with the young man who is the son of the originator! Go there.. support it and enjoy yourself while you meet many of the locals!“

“Ambiance... what is it ( look it up). Hollywood has the Best. Wait Staff - Hollywood has the Best. The food is Great and the Owners are Friendly and Visable. Not just the best in Cortland. The Best in CNY.“