$$ • Pizza, Italian

34 New St, Huntington
(631) 629-4551


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Eatalia

I’ve eaten at Eatallia countless times over the years. I’ve had them cater/host countless events as well, at my home, my husbands job, my daughters communion, my father in laws wake and we’ve referred a great deal of business to them because of our consistent pleasant experiences at Eatallia. The food has always been great but even better than the food, was the service. Vinny always took great care of his patrons I had intended on having them cater my other full review
Very dishonest business. I ordered multiple items for takeout from their menu. Upon picking up and arriving at home I realized that the entire Pie wasn't given to me. I called about my missing pie and they responded that they "didn't give it to me and didn't charge me for it" .We went over the pricing and the pricing didn't add up. They then said  "that the webmaster didn't update the online prices and prices went up." Anyways, They said they would amend the pricing and full review

We were a party of 4, my husband and our best friends who are from Huntington. We came for dinner. We had the burrata to start which was very yummy, angel hair pasta with red sauce (which wasn't on the menu, but they were able to make for us), chicken Florentine and Orecchiette. All family style for us, 4 which was just right and we had leftovers as well. Each dish was good, we will come back!

More Reviews(96)


Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 9PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.