Pizza, Italian

34 New St, Huntington
(631) 629-4551


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Eatalia

They were very nice while I placed the order. We Ordered baked ziti with meatballs, baked ziti was extremely dry, no flavor at all. Meatballs tasted as if from a bag down the frozen isle. Grandma pizza was extremely salty. Soups were bland. Garlic nots were extremely hard and old. We spent over $50 dollars for dinner. Very very disappointed. No one could eat it and the food went to the trash. Never again will I order from this place.

Simply the best! If you are in the mood for absolutely delicious Italian food, this is the place. I frequently order take-out from them and the pasta is always cooked perfectly, and the salads are always fresh. Portions are always generous. The restaurant itself is beautiful and a very welcoming space. Please don't ever leave Huntington!! You guys are awesome!!

Really disappointed! The food was terrible. The pasta fagioli soup had barely any beans or pasta but plenty of undercooked celery and carrots. The salad came next which was just a bed of spinach drenched in this horrible oil. Maybe 5 nuts and a few crumbles of cheese, tops about 4 slices of mandarins? For an $18 salad you think it would be well done. We asked for a small side dish of pasta. It was $16! The alcoholic drinks were definitely watered down. Very expensive, left full review

More Reviews(73)


Monday 11AM - 10PM
Tuesday 11AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.