18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Huntington

Dough & Co. Pizza Pizza • $
318 Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Metro Pizza at Dough & Co
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Spicy Vodka Sicilian
Margherita Slice
Metro East Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Slice
Slice of Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Regular Pizza

“The owner of D&C apparently learned his craft at Umberto's so I was very tempted to try the Sicilian but Newsday really hyped their "pizza al metro", which is also a different type of rectangular pie. It reminds me of the pizza shops we visited in Rome. Some of the Roman pizza shops would sell "pizza al metro" (pizza by the metre), where they make long sheets of pizza and you would specify what length you wanted based on metres (or partial metres).ORDERING TIP: When ordering a metro pie, you actually get two pizza boxes worth of pizza as you can see from the picture. Each box has 6 above average sized square slices (versus 9 slices you usually get from a Sicilian pie) so keep that in mind when ordering. The squares are a little larger than an average sicilian but they are thinner than at Umberto's so the premium pricing is somewhat justified based purely on size. However, from a taste perspective, I am not so sure because I had a couple of issues with the metro Margherita pizza. First, the sauce to cheese ratio is very skewed towards being very saucy and the sauce is very acidic/tangy, which would not be that bad if there was more cheese providing richness to balance the acidity/tangy. But as you can see from the pics, the cheese is more of an afterthought rather than a co-star. Second, the dough is a bit dense, which I think is strange because it is supposed to be super-high hydration dough. The undercarriage is pretty good and there is a good amount of the bubbles that are characteristic of high hydration dough, but strangely, the airiness through the rest of the dough was missing.Given the owner's background, Ihave to come back and try their Siclian.“

4.7 Superb85 Reviews
Gustoso Pizzeria Pizza • $
340 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza and BBQ Chicken and Bacon Ranch Pizza
Sicilian Pizza and Marinera Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Boneless Wings
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Fried Oreos
Can

“We just met the *NEW* owner, Eric! What a genuine guy who makes some delicious food! We placed a very large order, and Eric was such a pleasure to speak with. His personality is just was warm as the pizza we ordered! Not only did he carefully make and package our large order, but he so sweetly gave us 3 slices as my brother, my mom, and myself waited for our order after hearing they’re in town from Florida and were so excited for pizza! The stuffed zeppolis are a quick way to an Italian girls heart, and they aced them. Highly recommend checking out this place under their new ownership. Thank you so much for everything Eric! Best of luck with the new digs, and definitely recommend checking them out!“

4.9 Superb41 Reviews
Tony's Tacos Huntington Tacos • $
281 Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Tacos Chicken Parm Taco Meatball Parm
Taco Alla Scarpetta Birria
Churro Dulce de Leche
Cauliflower Explosion
Steak Supreme
Smoked Salmon
Octopus Taco
Chicken Club
Cheese Pizza
Surf & Turf

“I was very skeptical of this place at first, but it was amazing. So the concept is Italian-Mexican food. It works. And it works very well.We ordered 3 tacos as well as the surf and turf quesadilla. I was absolutely blown away by the taste and quality of everything. The quesadilla was one of the best I've had in a long time. The steak was juicy, the shrimp wasn't chewy, and the flavors were amazing. For tacos, we got the ital-Americano, chicken parm, and maialino. Every one was tasty in its own way. The Ital-Americano was super juicy, the chicken parm was just delicious chicken parm in a shell, and the mialino was juicy with just the right amount of spice.I need to remember next time to sign up for the rewards program since I know I'll be back there a lot.Parking: Parking all over.“

4.5 Superb112 Reviews
Di Raimo Pizzeria Pizza • $
76 Wall St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza and Reg Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza & Veggie Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Cheese Pizza Slice
Side of Meatballs
Gorgonzola Salad
The White Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Sicilian Pie
Chicken Roll

“Good pizza always enjoy the Sicilian corner slice and the hero's are very good and of course I love the chicken parm Modesto DiRaimo God rest his soul left a legacy in Huntington that his family is carrying on also they have parking which is a plus in Huntington been going here since I was a baby and always will come here God bless“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Marciano's Pizza Truck Pizza Delivery •
185 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Nonna Pizza

“Can’t thank Jennifer and the Marciano’s team enough for making a super rainy day a blast for my wife’s birthday. The food was excellent, they were flexible and so well organized. Nothing but positive things to say and we’ll most definitely be a repeat client. Thanks team!- Evan“

5 Superb16 Reviews
Junior's Pizza Pizza • $
142 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Parm Hero
Gluten Free Pizza

“We were working on a job nearby Junior’s Pizza, so my crew and I frequented Junior’s at least once a week. The food is amazing, staff extremely nice and helpful. Highly recommend coming here!Get the chicken bacon/bbq sauce pizza .. it’s super good!!“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
Teresa's Pizza Box Pizza • $
762 Park Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni & Chicken Cutlet
Regular Slice
Sicilian Pie
Grandma

“What a great place. I happened to be in the area and stopped in for lunch. Much more than just sandwiches! They have soup and a steam table. I sat at a small counter and observed a Steady traffic of customers. Many seemed like regulars. Lots of friendly chatter between the good sized staff and customers. If I am in the area, I will surely come back.“

4.3 Superb34 Reviews
Rocco's Pizza & Catering Pizza • $
247 Broadway Greenlawn, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Alla Vodka-Perfectly Seasoned Ponk Sauce
Drunken Grandma Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Roll
Chicken Parmigiana
Pepperoni Bites
Cheese Pizza
Meatballs

“Rocco’s is our spot for pizza in my family! In my opinion, it’s the best around! Their Drunken Grandma pie is outstanding! I recently tried the hero and it was equally good. One of my other personal favorites is the “upside down” Sicilian pie!We have also used Rocco’s for catering and they have always come through with delicious food. If you haven’t tried this spot, you won’t be disappointed!“

4.3 Superb31 Reviews
Jonny D's Pizza Pizza • $
946 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak with Mozzarella Cheese
Slice Pizza Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sausage Pepper & Onion Parm Hero
Sausage Parmigiana Hero
Jonny D's Jumbo Wings
Greek Chicken Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Broccoli Roll

“One of my favorite pizza spots in all of Huntington. I had a regular slice and a grandma slice today and they were both delicious and pipping hot. Jonny D's is always very clean, and the music is nice. Everyone smiles when you enter as well, that's always a good sign. The photos are of old Huntington from back in the day. Gives you something as a reminder of how far the town has come. I had a great lunch!!!“

4.2 Good47 Reviews
1653 Pizza Company Pizza • $$
80 Gerard St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Prosciutto
Margherita Pizza
Bacon Jam Pizza
White Clam Pie
Pesto Lasagne
Caesar Salad
Margherita
The Gerard
Sausage
1653

“If you are looking for something different give this place a try. I’ve lived here for years and always thought this was another pizzeria. It’s not. They have pizza but more of an authentic homemade style along with many other Italian specialties. Chicken vodka parm hero was amazing. Pasta was the perfect type of al dente. Will be back for sure“

4.1 Good83 Reviews
Little Vincent's Pizza Pizza • $
329 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Large Pie with Fresh Mozzarella
Cold Cheese Pizza Slice
Regular Pizza Slice
Cold Cheese Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
New York Pizza

“This pizza spots lands in my top two in the world. I don’t know what type of crazy magic they use to make pizza but it’s perfect. I don’t even want toppings because the pizza hot out of the oven is one of the best things I’ve ever had.“

4.1 Good71 Reviews
La Nonna's Pizza • $$
75 E Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Crispino Pizza Slice
Extra Sides of Blue Cheese
Grandma a La Vodka Pizza
La Nonnas Stuffed Knots
Grandma Ala Vodka Slice
Judy's Creation Pizza
Italian Wedding Soup
Chicken Noodle Soup
Eggplant Rollatini
Pasta Fagioli Soup

“I had a full tray of baked ziti and full tray of chicken cutlet parm delivered through the slice app. The chicken cutlet were so tender and delicious. the trays were packed full and the sauce was one of the best I've had! Thank you so much!!Peggy“

4.1 Good44 Reviews

13
Eatalia

Eatalia Italian • $$
34 New St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Chicken Florentine
Veal Parmigiana
Fried Calamari
Crab

“My family and I were surprised to see some empty tables on Valentine’s Day and even more surprised after we had an amazing dinner. Fresh and delicious food at reasonable prices. Best chicken parm I ever had (tastefully breaded with tender organic chicken), crispy pizzas and fresh/large fish filet portion. Service was friendly and quick. Chef knows what they’re doing back there. Please come and eat here for the sake of yourselves and us because we want this place to last and you will too!“

4 Good32 Reviews
Portofino Italian • $
395 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Brooklyn Pie
Italian
Ln

“We recently went to PortoFino with some friends for an early dinner. The new owner, Tony, greeted us and could not have been nicer. We had a terrific dinner, and everything was fantastic. The entire staff were incredible. Great job Tony! We will definitely come back.“

4 Good50 Reviews
Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint Pizza • $$
376 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Plain Jane – 18 Inch
New White Truffle 12
Philly Cheese Steak
The Blvd
Pizza

“Their pizza is soooo good!!! So many different slices to choose from and all fresh! The sit down area is small but has really cool graffiti art on the walls to look at! They play great music and are open pretty late! I would highly recommend this place. It's my go to pizza spot now!“

4 Good62 Reviews
Rosa's Pizza Pizza • $
313 Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Penne Ala Vodka Margherita Ravioli and Vodka Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Chicken Bacon Honey
Pepperoni Pizza and Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Caesar Salad Pie
Mozzarella Tomato Pizza
Grandma Vodka Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots

“This pizza is delicious! Nice crunch crust on the outside, soft inside. Perfect amount of sauce & cheese. They also have a variety of dishes from sandwiches, pastas & other Italian entrees. Definitely be back for another slice & looking forward to trying out their other dishes as well!“

3.8 Good73 Reviews
Umberto's Pizzeria Pizza • $
737 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza
Simple Salad Perfection
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Linguini and Clam
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Francese
Marinara Sauce
Sicilian Pizza
Garlic Knots
Baked Ziti

“since they spent the money on trying to get new customers with coupon ads in the hometown shopper, i clipped a coupon, picked up the phone and ordered for the superbowl to give it a try. the food was ready and hot upon my pickup as they promised and my guests just devoured the meatball hero; the pizza and the italian cold cut hero also delicious. The price was quite fair-2 3 footers, 4 pizzas and more garlic knots than we could eat and... i'm certain i'll be back again.“

3.7 Good59 Reviews
Ella's Taverna and Pizza Napoletana Pizza • $$
364 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Bread and Butter Appetizer
Ricotta Gnocchi
Pesto Pizza
Skirt Steak
Calamari
Sauce

“The chicken parm is truly a show stopper - I'd drive well out of my way for it/to get to Ella's again.Combine that with great service at the bar, solid drinks and apps and i'd absolutely go back to Ella's for a night out or before/after the paramount.“

3.6 Good99 Reviews
Loading...
map Map