Cayuga Lake Creamery
$ • Ice Cream, Fast FoodAbout Cayuga Lake Creamery
Customers' Favorites
Hard Ice Cream or Sorbet
Mocha Chocolate Chunk
Soft Serve Custard
Waffle Cone or Dish
Sea Salt Caramel
Waffle Cones
Three Scoops
Purple Cow
Sundaes
Cayuga Lake Creamery Reviews
266 ratings
Share your opinion about Cayuga Lake Creamery
My daughter and I love coming here and just sharing a delicious scoop of the best ice cream in town! Definitely worth it
so many flavors to choose from, all so delicious! We had them cater at our wedding ❤️
I’ve stopped here multiple times for their dairy-free mango passion fruit sorbet, and it’s absolutely amazing! So delicious and definitely worth coming back for even if it's out of our way! 🥭🍨
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 2 - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 2 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 2 - 8PM |
| Friday | 2 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Cayuga Lake Creamery is a beloved ice cream shop that delights visitors with its high-quality, homemade ice cream. The creamery features a massive flavor menu that rotates seasonally, offering a wide range of options, from classic favorites like Butter Pecan and Pistachio to unique flavors like Ginger, Lavender, and Jalapeno Popper. The ice cream is made with great care, using quality dairy and ingredients, and without excessive sugar, allowing the natural flavors to shine.
Customers can enjoy their scoops in a variety of ways, including hard-serve, soft-serve, custard, and sundaes. The portions are described as fair and appropriate for the price, although some customers note that single serve prices are high compared to buying a pint or quart, making larger sizes a better value. The creamery also offers some savory food options for those who want more than just dessert, with plenty of vegetarian choices and options for dietary restrictions, including sorbets for vegans and gluten-free selections.
The atmosphere at Cayuga Lake Creamery is typical of an ice cream shop, with both indoor and outdoor seating areas. While the interior may not be anything special, the outdoor seating down the hill provides a shaded area for enjoying delicious ice cream on a hot day. Overall, Cayuga Lake Creamery is a must-visit destination for anyone craving a delightful, high-quality ice cream experience.